Mid Island Apartments is more than just a place to call home. Our quality studio, one, and two-bedroom apartment homes have been upgraded to match your lifestyle. This quaint community, built with traditional brick architecture, is surrounded by expansive green courtyards and tucked into the historic Bay Shore neighborhood on Long Island, New York. Our recently remodeled, pet-friendly homes feature hardwood flooring, and stainless-steel appliances. Enticing outdoor adventure, delicious dining options, charming coffee shops, and highly rated schools are just minutes from Mid Island Apartments.
Apartment building
Studio-2 beds
Pet-friendly
Surface parking lot
In-unit laundry (W/D)
Available units
This listing now includes required monthly fees in the total monthly price. Price shown reflects the lease term provided for each unit.
Unit , sortable column | Sqft, sortable column | Available, sortable column | Total monthly price, sorted ascending |
|---|---|---|---|
 Unit 0631E Studio, 1 ba | 400 | Sep 16 | $2,075 |
Unit 0532B Studio, 1 ba | 400 | Oct 1 | $2,090 |
Unit 0551C Studio, 1 ba | 400 | Now | $2,155 |
 Unit 0211A 1 bd, 1 ba | 665 | Sep 16 | $2,305 |
Unit 0231D 1 bd, 1 ba | 665 | Oct 1 | $2,305 |
Unit 0112D 1 bd, 1 ba | 665 | Oct 1 | $2,500 |
Unit 0252A 1 bd, 1 ba | 665 | Sep 16 | $2,525 |
Unit 0151D 1 bd, 1 ba | 665 | Sep 18 | $2,545 |
 Unit 0531F 1 bd, 1 ba | 705 | Now | $2,550 |
Unit 0211D 1 bd, 1 ba | 665 | Nov 4 | $2,595 |
 Unit 0672B 2 bd, 1 ba | 820 | Sep 27 | $2,695 |
 Unit 0692B 2 bd, 1 ba | 840 | Sep 15 | $2,755 |
Unit 0252B 2 bd, 1 ba | 820 | Now | $2,775 |
 Unit 0152B 2 bd, 1.5 ba | 875 | Oct 3 | $2,805 |
Unit 0272C 2 bd, 1 ba | 820 | Now | $2,840 |
Listings by: Listing by: Eagle Rock Management
What's special
Playground
Play date, anyone?
A playground is a rare feature. Less than 19% of buildings in Suffolk County have this amenity.
Traditional brick architectureRecently remodeledHardwood flooringStainless-steel appliances
Office hours
| Day | Open hours |
|---|---|
| Mon - Fri: | 9 am - 5:30 pm |
| Sat: | 9 am - 5:30 pm |
| Sun: | Closed |
Facts, features & policies
Building Amenities
Other
- In Unit: Washer/Dryer (in Select Apartment Homes)
- Laundry: Shared
Outdoor common areas
- Playground
Services & facilities
- On-Site Maintenance
- On-Site Management
Unit Features
Appliances
- Dishwasher
- Dryer
- Washer: Washer/Dryer (in Select Apartment Homes)
Cooling
- Air Conditioning: Air Conditioner
Flooring
- Wood
Internet/Satellite
- High-Speed Internet Ready
Other
- Backsplash
- Bathroom Reno
- Quartz/Granite Counter
Policies
Parking
- Surface Lot
Lease terms
- 12 months
Pet essentials
- Medium dogsAllowed
- DogsAllowedMonthly dog rent$50
- Medium catsAllowed
- CatsAllowedMonthly cat rent$50
Special Features
- Newly Renovated Apartment Homes (in Select Apartment Homes)
- Open Lot Parking
- Short Term Lease Options
- Stainless Steel Appliances (in Select Apartment Homes)
- Smoke-free building
Neighborhood: 11706
Areas of interest
Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.
Travel times
Getting around
Walk Score®
/ 100
Somewhat WalkableBike Score®
/ 100
Somewhat BikeableNear Mid Island Apartments
- The Islip Public Library, offering programs such as Once Upon a Playtime, Digital Photography for All Digital Cameras, Aboard!, Defensive Driving and Laughing Around the World, is a 5-minute drive.
- Circle of One Martial Arts, located within a 5-minute drive, offers classes including martial arts, kickboxing, Warriors Kids, Little Ninjas and special-needs karate.
- Bay Shore Mini Golf, the largest mini golf course in Long Island, featuring three separate miniature golf courses with waterfall features and obstacles, is a 5-minute drive.
- The Himes Museum of Motor Racing Nostalgia, located within a 5-minute walk of the community, features hands-on and interactive exhibits, artifacts and memorabilia.
Nearby schools in Bay Shore
Brook Avenue Elementary School
Grades K-2 • 0.5 milesN/A
GreatSchools® Rating
Bay Shore Middle School
Grades 6-8 • 1.2 miles5/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
5/10Student Progress Rating
5/10Bay Shore Senior High School
Grades 9-12 • 0.9 miles6/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
7/10College Readiness Rating
4/10Living in Bay Shore
- Community VibeA strong sense of community is fostered through local events and gatherings, bringing neighbors together.
- Dining SceneA delightful array of restaurants and cafes offers diverse dining options, catering to various tastes.
- Family VibesThis area is dotted with playgrounds and recreational centers, perfect for family activities and bonding.
- Green SpacesNumerous parks and nature trails invite residents to enjoy the outdoors and engage in recreational activities.
The 11706 area offers a charming suburban lifestyle with a mix of natural beauty and community spirit, characterized by spacious parks and family-friendly amenities. Residents enjoy a range of local grocery stores, coffee shops, and casual dining options, while the nearby parks provide ample opportunities for outdoor activities and relaxation. With a median rent of approximately $2,600, the rental prices typically range from $2,000 to $3,200, making it accessible for various budgets. The neighborhood's inviting atmosphere, combined with a focus on family-oriented spaces and pet-friendly parks, makes it a welcoming place to call home.
Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.
Nearby apartments for rent
Listing order may reflect relevance, quality, and paid promotion.
Similar apartments for rent
Frequently asked questions
Mid Island Apartments is located at 35 Penataquit Ave in Bay Shore, NY. The surrounding area includes approximately 20 restaurants and cafes within 1 mile, such as Tropical Smoothie Cafe, Starbucks, and Retro Fitness.
The nearest public transit stop is LIRR - Bay Shore Station, approximately 0.8 miles away.
Mid Island Apartments is located within 0.5 miles of Pro Game Athletics, 0.6 miles of Citibank, and 0.6 miles of Homan Ave Dock.
Mid Island Apartments is located near 3 grocery stores, including 0.4 miles from Stop & Shop, 0.4 miles from Wines on Main, and 0.7 miles from Deans Seafood. Additional shopping options, including New Feeling Nail Spa, are approximately 0.6 miles away.
The total price for an apartment unit in Mid Island Apartments ranges from $2,075 to $3,115. The total price will vary by floor plan, unit size, and unit amenities.
The closest hospitals and medical facilities to Mid Island Apartments include Northwell Health (0.2 miles away), Southside Hospital ICU Waiting Room (0.2 miles away), and Suffolk Surgical Associates (0.2 miles away).
Mid Island Apartments is near approximately 20 restaurants within 1 mile, including Tropical Smoothie Cafe (0.4 miles away), Starbucks (0.5 miles away), and Retro Fitness (0.5 miles away).
The schools assigned to Mid Island Apartments include Brook Avenue Elementary School, Bay Shore Middle School, and Bay Shore Senior High School.
There are 7+ floor plans availableWith 41% more variety than properties in the area, you're sure to find a place that fits your lifestyle.
