Skip main navigation
Zillow logo
  • 728 Elizabeth St

    Key West, FL 33040

    Apartment building
    2 beds
    In-unit laundry (W/D)

    Available units

    To contact, request a tour, or apply, select a unit below. Each unit has its own contact details.

    This listing now includes required monthly fees in the total monthly price. Price shown reflects the lease term provided for each unit.

    Unit
    , sortable column
    Sqft, sortable columnAvailable, sortable columnTotal monthly price, sorted ascending
    --
    2 bd, 1 ba
    690
    Dec 1
    $3,900

    What's special

    New appliancesAbundance of natural lightDistinctive upper levelFrench doorsSeparate open loft areaCozy second bedroomSpacious bedroom
    Unique Historic Old Town Apartment | Annual Lease | Available December 1, 2026 2 Bedrooms | 1 Bathroom | Private Balcony | Newly Renovated | Heart of Old Town Key West Discover a truly unique living space in the heart of Old Town Key West! Located just 3 blocks from Duval Street and 5 blocks from the Historic Seaport, this beautifully renovated apartment occupies the second and third floors of a charming historic triplex on Elizabeth Street. Freshly updated throughout, the apartment features a brand-new kitchen with new appliances, in-unit laundry, all-new impact windows, fresh interior & exterior paint and newly installed Mitsubishi ductless air-conditioning units in each living and bedroom areas, providing efficient, individually controlled comfort. Soaring ceilings, an open and airy floor plan, and an abundance of natural light create a wonderful sense of space. The main living level offers a spacious bedroom, full bathroom, and an open-concept living, dining, and kitchen area. French doors lead to a generous covered balcony overlooking Elizabeth Street, providing the perfect spot for morning coffee, outdoor dining, or simply enjoying the Old Town atmosphere. What truly sets this apartment apart is its distinctive upper level. A staircase leads to a cozy second bedroom and a separate open loft area, connected by a dramatic catwalk overlooking the living space below. These versatile spaces offer exciting possibilities for guest accommodations, home offices, creative studios, a fitness area, or additional lounging space. Several A.I. Decorated photos are included in the listing to illustrate some of the many possibilities. New custom stairs are being installed, with the apartment scheduled to be ready for occupancy December 1, 2026. This one-of-a-kind property is an excellent option for full-time Key West residents, couples seeking separate work-from-home spaces, or seasonal residents who would prefer the convenience and flexibility of securing a year-round home rather than searching for high-season rentals each year. Enjoy the charm of historic Old Town, the convenience of a walkable location, and the flexibility of a thoughtfully renovated, truly distinctive home. Annual Lease | Available December 1, 2026 No tours will be scheduled without a phone call taking place first - no exceptions. Minimum 12 month lease First month plus security required for move-in Last month required but will give 3 month split payment option on a 12 month lease Tenant pays water & power No smoking Pets considered on a case by case basis Tenants required to clean ductless a/c permanent filters every 30-60 days to maintain good working conditions Tenants responsible for their own pest control other than termites - property just termite tented in October 2026 and is under warranty

    Facts, features & policies

    Unit features

    Appliances
    • Dishwasher
    • Dryer
    • Microwave oven
    • Oven
    • Refrigerator
    • Washer
    Flooring
    • Hardwood
    • Tile

    Neighborhood: Old Town

    Areas of interest

    Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.

    Travel times

    Getting around

    Walk Score®
     / 100
    Walker's Paradise
    Transit Score®
     / 100
    Some Transit
    Bike Score®
     / 100
    Biker's Paradise

    Nearby schools in Key West

    Horace O'bryant School
    Grades PK-8 • 0.8 miles
    3/10
    GreatSchools® Rating
    Test Score Rating
    3/10
    Student Progress Rating
    3/10
    Key West High School
    Grades 9-12 • 1.4 miles
    3/10
    GreatSchools® Rating
    Test Score Rating
    3/10
    College Readiness Rating
    5/10
    Student Progress Rating
    2/10

    Old Town occupies the historic heart of Key West, on the island’s western end, where compact streets, tropical greenery and pastel buildings reflect its maritime past. The subtropical climate brings warm, humid weather and seasonal rain, while ocean breezes shape outdoor life. Landmarks include the Ernest Hemingway Home and Museum, the Key West Lighthouse and the Harry S. Truman Little White House; nearby, Mallory Square is known for sunset gatherings. Dining ranges from seafood restaurants to casual cafés, with independent shops and galleries along Duval Street. The area also has bars, live music and historic architecture. The Old Town neighborhood’s median rent is $6,000 per month, with a typical range of $2,800 to $21,000. Walking and cycling are practical on the compact street grid, and local buses connect parts of the island.

    Powered by Zillow data and AI technology.

    Loading

    Frequently asked questions

    Where is 728 Elizabeth St located, and what is the neighborhood like?

    728 Elizabeth St is located at 728 Elizabeth St in Old Town, Key West, FL. The surrounding area includes multiple restaurants and cafes within 2 miles, such as Better Than Sex, DJ's Clam Shack, and Key West Cuban Coffee.

    What hospitals and medical facilities are near 728 Elizabeth St?

    The closest hospitals and medical facilities to 728 Elizabeth St include Truman Medical (0.2 miles away), IV's In The Keys (0.3 miles away), and Roosevelt Sands Community Health Resource Center (0.5 miles away).

    What schools are assigned to 728 Elizabeth St?

    The schools assigned to 728 Elizabeth St include Horace O'bryant School and Key West High School.

    What are the grocery stores and everyday shopping options near 728 Elizabeth St?

    728 Elizabeth St is located near 3 grocery stores, including Fausto's Food Palace (0.3 miles) and Johnson's Grocery (0.4 miles). Additional shopping options, including Books & Books, are approximately 0.3 miles away.

    What colleges and universities are near 728 Elizabeth St?

    728 Elizabeth St is located within 0.4 miles of Alderedson City Cottage and 0.5 miles of Nutrition-Truman School.

    ]