Castaway Cove

9226 Midnight Pass Rd, Sarasota, FL 34242

Apartment building

2 beds

Available units

Filter

To contact, request a tour, or apply, select a unit below. Each unit has its own contact details.

Price may not include required fees and charges.

Unit , sortable column	Sqft, sortable column	Available, sortable column	Base rent, sorted ascending
Unit 4A 2 bd, 2 ba	1,223	Now	Fees may apply $3,500
Unit 1A 2 bd, 2 ba	1,223	Now	Fees may apply $4,000

Neighborhood: 34242

Areas of interest

Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.

Travel times

Getting around

Walk Score^®

/ 100

Car-Dependent

Transit Score^®

/ 100

No Nearby Transit

Nearby schools in Sarasota

Phillippi Shores Elementary School

Grades PK-5 • 5.1 miles

9/10

GreatSchools^® Rating

Test Score Rating

9/10

Student Progress Rating

9/10

Brookside Middle School

Grades 6-8 • 6.1 miles

7/10

GreatSchools^® Rating

Test Score Rating

6/10

Student Progress Rating

7/10

Sarasota High School

Grades 9-12 • 7.7 miles

5/10

GreatSchools^® Rating

Test Score Rating

6/10

College Readiness Rating

4/10

Student Progress Rating

4/10

Beach Access
Siesta Beach and other public shoreline access points make the Gulf coast a defining feature of the area.
Outdoor Activities
Beach walks, biking, and snorkeling near Point of Rocks are among the outdoor options.
Dining Scene
The island’s village area offers cafés and restaurants alongside local shops.
Water Sports
The Gulf and bay provide opportunities for snorkeling, paddling, and other water activities.

Bay Isle-Siesta and Bailey Hall sit on Siesta Key, a barrier island between the Gulf of Mexico and Sarasota Bay, with a warm, humid coastal climate. The area is known for Siesta Beach’s broad, quartz-sand shoreline; Point of Rocks adds a limestone outcrop and clear-water snorkeling spot. Parks, beach access points, and nearby trails offer room for walks and outdoor recreation, while the island’s village area brings together cafés, restaurants, and shops. Local history and coastal scenery shape a relaxed island pace, with arts and evening entertainment available around the village. Getting around is easiest by car, bicycle, or on foot for nearby errands, and bridges connect the key to Sarasota. For ZIP code 34242, the median rent is $7,500 per month, with a typical range of $1,500 to $37,000.