136 N Arlington Ave, Lancaster, OH 43130

Pinterest-worthy Cape Cod with timeless charm and nearly every major update already done. Full of charm and completely Pinterest-worthy, this beautifully updated Cape Cod blends timeless character with modern updates in all the right places. Originally built in 1937, this home offers the warmth and charm you'd expect from a classic Cape Cod while nearly every major component has been thoughtfully updated in the last three years. The kitchen has been completely renovated, the bathroom was fully updated within the past year, and the original wood floors have been beautifully refinished. Additional improvements include newer HVAC, new siding, new windows, new exterior doors, and a new garage door, offering both style and peace of mind. The spacious finished attic provides incredible flexibility and is currently used as a third bedroom but could easily function as a cozy family room, home office, playroom, or creative space. Outside, enjoy relaxing evenings on the backyard patio beneath a large mature tree that provides shade and privacy to the space. Conveniently located with quick access to Route 33, making for an easy commute to Columbus while still enjoying the charm and character of Lancaster living. If you love homes with personality, character, and thoughtful updates, this one is truly special. **Multiple offers have been received. Please submit all offers by noon on Saturday 3/14/2026 and leave offers open until 4:00 p.m. Saturday for seller review. Thank you!