16 S Elihu Pl, Montauk, NY 11954

Rental Registration #: 23-365 Experience the best of Montauk living in this beautifully updated single family home, where modern comfort meets an unbeatable coastal lifestyle. Offering 4 bedrooms, 2 bathrooms, and approximately 1,400 square feet, this original Carl Fisher residence features a thoughtfully renovated first floor with a refreshed kitchen, updated bathroom, stainless steel appliances, a convenient first floor primary bedroom, and a full first floor bath. Outside, the large, lush backyard creates a private retreat with a welcoming fire pit area that is perfect for relaxing or entertaining. Ideally located within walking distance to both the beach and downtown Montauk, you'll enjoy easy access to local shops, restaurants, and waterfront experiences while coming home to a space designed for everyday comfort and effortless coastal living. Available year-round starting in September 2026. RR#: 23-365