Don’t miss this rare opportunity to own a distinguished piece of Port Jefferson history. Originally built in 1890 for renowned sea captain Llewellyn Tuthill, this exceptional residence has been thoughtfully maintained and tastefully updated while honoring the craftsmanship and architectural character of its era. Set back and elevated above the roadway, the home commands attention with its stately presence and inviting wraparound porch.
Inside, timeless period details abound, including soaring 10-foot ceilings, original custom woodwork, wide-plank flooring, antique push-button switches, decorative hardware, and beautifully restored cast-iron radiators. Stunning original pocket doors gracefully separate the living room from the entrance hallway, adding both architectural elegance and functional design rarely found today.
Modern improvements blend seamlessly with the historic charm and include radiant heated flooring in the bathroom, a finished attic offering flexible bonus space, a newer roof, rebuilt chimneys, and a refinished fireplace.
Ideally situated in the Historic Village of Port Jefferson, just moments from the harbor, village shops, dining, and amenities, and located within the highly regarded Port Jefferson School District—this is a truly special offering where history, character, and lifestyle come together.
Sold for $925,000
$925,000
204 Myrtle Avenue, Port Jefferson, NY 11777
4beds
2,854sqft
Single Family Residence, Residential
Built in 1894
0.25 Acres Lot
$939,900 Zestimate®
$324/sqft
$2,922 Estimated rent
Home value
$939,900
$846,000 - $1.04M
$2,922/mo
Zestimate® history
Owner options
List your home for rent
$2,922/mo
Rent Zestimate®
Find your next renter with Zillow Rental Manager. Plus, with online applications, you can quickly screen prospective tenants – for free.
$2,922/mo
Rent Zestimate®
Refinance and save
$6,384/mo
Est. payment
Refinancing to a lower rate could help reduce your monthly payments and save thousands over the life of the loan.
$6,384/mo
Est. payment
Explore your selling options
Work with a Zillow partner agent
Leverage their expertise and Zillow's premium Showcase listings to get your home seen by more buyers.
Get startedList with your own agent
Get your home in front of millions of buyers by listing it on Zillow.
Learn how to do itSell it yourself
Take full control of how buyers see your home on Zillow by listing For Sale by Owner (FSBO).
List your homeWhat's special
Refinished fireplaceBeautifully restored cast-iron radiatorsNewer roofOriginal custom woodworkRebuilt chimneysStunning original pocket doorsDecorative hardware
Zillow last checked:
Listing updated:
Listed by:
Eric Peskin 631-522-6218,
Signature Premier Properties 631-751-2111,
Zachary Scher CBR 631-974-2609,
Signature Premier Properties
Bought with:
Nicole L. Schwartz, 10401399547
RE/MAX City Square
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID,MLS#: 949994
Facts & features
Interior
Bedrooms & bathrooms
- Bedrooms: 4
- Bathrooms: 2
- Full bathrooms: 2
Heating
- Oil, Radiant, Steam
Cooling
- None
Appliances
- Included: Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Washer, Oil Water Heater
Features
- First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, Granite Counters, Kitchen Island
- Flooring: Carpet, Hardwood
- Basement: Bilco Door(s),Full
- Attic: Finished
- Number of fireplaces: 1
- Fireplace features: Family Room, Wood Burning
Interior area
- Total structure area: 2,854
- Total interior livable area: 2,854 sqft
Property
Parking
- Total spaces: 2
- Parking features: Driveway, Garage
- Garage spaces: 2
- Has uncovered spaces: Yes
Features
- Levels: Three Or More
Lot
- Size: 0.25 Acres
- Features: Back Yard, Cleared, Historic District, Level, Near School, Near Shops
Details
- Parcel number: 0206016000200035000
- Special conditions: None
Construction
Type & style
- Home type: SingleFamily
- Architectural style: Colonial
- Property subtype: Single Family Residence, Residential
Materials
- Vinyl Siding
Condition
- Year built: 1894
- Major remodel year: 1894
Utilities & green energy
- Sewer: Public Sewer
- Water: Public
- Utilities for property: Electricity Connected, Natural Gas Connected, Water Connected
Community & HOA
HOA
- Has HOA: No
Location
- Region: Port Jefferson
Financial & listing details
- Price per square foot: $324/sqft
- Tax assessed value: $3,150
- Annual tax amount: $11,632
- Date on market: 1/15/2026
- Cumulative days on market: 19 days
- Listing agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
- Electric utility on property: Yes
Price history
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 4/2/2026 | Sold | $925,000+2.9%$324/sqft |
Source:  OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #949994 Report a problem | ||
| 2/3/2026 | Pending sale | $899,000$315/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #949994 Report a problem | ||
| 1/15/2026 | Listed for sale | $899,000+25%$315/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #949994 Report a problem | ||
| 1/27/2023 | Listing removed | -- |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #H6228143 Report a problem | ||
| 1/18/2023 | Listed for sale | $719,000+21.9%$252/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #H6228143 Report a problem | ||
| 7/9/2021 | Sold | $590,000+6.5%$207/sqft |
Source: Agent Provided Report a problem | ||
| 11/22/2017 | Sold | $554,000+11.9%$194/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #L2955096 Report a problem | ||
| 12/3/2007 | Sold | $495,000-11.3%$173/sqft |
Source: Public Record Report a problem | ||
| 9/12/2003 | Sold | $558,000$196/sqft |
Source: Public Record Report a problem | ||
Public tax history
| Year | Property taxes | Tax assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2024 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2023 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2022 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2021 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2020 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2019 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2018 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2017 | $7,427 | $3,150 |
| 2016 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2015 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2014 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2013 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2012 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2011 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2010 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2009 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2008 | -- | $3,150 |
| 2007 | $5,698 +34.3% | $3,150 |
| 2005 | $4,243 +13.8% | $3,150 +6.8% |
| 2004 | $3,730 +5% | $2,950 |
| 2003 | $3,552 +4.4% | $2,950 |
| 2002 | $3,401 +1.6% | $2,950 |
| 2001 | $3,347 -4.2% | $2,950 |
| 2000 | $3,492 | $2,950 |
Find assessor info on the county website
Neighborhood: 11777
Nearby homes
- $916,400-- bd-- ba-- sqft202 Myrtle Ave, Port Jefferson, NY 11777Off Market
- $820,600-- bd-- ba-- sqft210 Myrtle Ave, Port Jefferson, NY 11777Off Market
- $711,9003 bd2 ba-- sqft806 High St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777Off Market
- $791,600-- bd-- ba-- sqft113 Hawkins St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777Off Market
- $697,0003 bd2 ba1.7k sqft808 High St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777Sold
- $717,5004 bd2 ba-- sqft111 Hawkins St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777Off Market
- $244,186-- bd-- ba-- sqft301 Myrtle Ave, Port jefferson, NY 11777Off Market
- $604,200-- bd-- ba-- sqft305 Myrtle Ave, Port Jefferson, NY 11777Off Market
Nearby schools
GreatSchools rating
- 5/10Port Jefferson Elementary SchoolGrades: PK-5Distance: 0.4 mi
- 8/10Port Jefferson Middle SchoolGrades: 6-8Distance: 0.5 mi
- 9/10Earl L Vandermeulen High SchoolGrades: 9-12Distance: 0.5 mi
Schools provided by the listing agent
- Elementary: Port Jefferson Elementary School
- Middle: Port Jefferson Middle School
- High: Earl L Vandermeulen High School
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. This data may not be complete. We recommend contacting the local school district to confirm school assignments for this home.
Get a cash offer in 3 minutes
Find out how much your home could sell for in as little as 3 minutes with a no-obligation cash offer.
Estimated market value
$939,900
Get a cash offer in 3 minutes
Find out how much your home could sell for in as little as 3 minutes with a no-obligation cash offer.
Estimated market value
$939,900
- New York
- Suffolk County
- Port Jefferson
- 11777
- 204 Myrtle Avenue
Nearby cities
Nearby zip codes
Other Port Jefferson Topics
