Rental Registration #: 2026-L-0067 Welcome to 23 Osprey Road, Shelter Island-a beautifully renovated retreat offering privacy, tranquility, and the best of island living. Available for summer or year-round rental, this exceptional property sits on over an acre of landscaped grounds with peaceful pond views and direct adjacency to Dusty Boots Farm, where horses can often be seen grazing nearby. A charming front porch welcomes you into the foyer, complete with a convenient powder room. Beyond, you'll find a chef-inspired eat-in kitchen designed for both everyday living and entertaining. The spacious living room features a wood-burning fireplace and opens to the backyard, creating a seamless indoor-outdoor experience. The main level also includes a primary suite with its own en-suite bathroom, while a screened porch provides the perfect place to relax and enjoy the surrounding natural beauty throughout the seasons. An attached two-car garage adds convenience and ample storage. Upstairs, a versatile sitting area or salon is accompanied by a laundry closet with washer and dryer. Two additional bedrooms offer generous closet space, including a second en-suite bedroom ideal for guests or extended family. The unfinished basement provides abundant storage space for seasonal belongings, recreational equipment, and more. Residents enjoy access to a private beach and tennis court just down the block, while Wades Beach, the South Ferry, and many of Shelter Island's beloved destinations are less than five minutes away. [[Rental Registration # 2026-L-0067]]
House for rent
Singlefamily
Available now
Air conditioner, central air
Garage parking
Fireplace
What's special
- 42 days |
- -- |
- -- |
Zillow last checked:
Listing updated:
Travel times

Let’s turn your rent into credit progress
Build credit history with every on-time payment and get credit for the payment you’re already making.
Facts & features
Interior
Bedrooms & bathrooms
- Bedrooms: 4
- Bathrooms: 4
- Full bathrooms: 3
- 1/2 bathrooms: 1
Heating
- Fireplace
Cooling
- Air Conditioner, Central Air
Features
- Has basement: Yes
- Has fireplace: Yes
Interior area
- Total interior livable area: 3,484 sqft
Property
Parking
- Parking features: Detached, Garage
- Has garage: Yes
- Details: Contact manager
Features
- Stories: 2
- Exterior features: Basement
- Has view: Yes
- View description: Water View
- Has water view: Yes
- Water view: Waterfront
Lot
- Features: Waterfront
Details
- Additional structures: Garage(s)
- Parcel number: 0700023000200078000
Construction
Type & style
- Home type: SingleFamily
- Architectural style: Ranch Rambler
- Property subtype: SingleFamily
Condition
- Year built: 2005
Community & HOA
Location
- Region: Shelter Island
Financial & listing details
- Lease term: Contact For Details
Price history
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 10/9/2026 | Listing removed | $1,895,000-5%$544/sqft |
Source: NY State MLS #11656162 Report a problem | ||
| 10/9/2026 | Listed for rent | $40,000-53.5%$11/sqft |
Source: Zillow Rentals #396217 Report a problem | ||
| 9/16/2026 | Listed for rent | $86,000+975%$25/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #1010703 Report a problem | ||
| 9/16/2026 | Listing removed | $8,000$2/sqft |
Source: Zillow Rentals #396217 Report a problem | ||
| 9/1/2026 | Price change | $8,000-65.2%$2/sqft |
Source: Zillow Rentals #396217 Report a problem | ||
| 8/24/2026 | Price change | $23,000-73.3%$7/sqft |
Source: Zillow Rentals #396217 Report a problem | ||
| 8/24/2026 | Listing removed | $1,995,000$573/sqft |
Source: Out East #393576 Report a problem | ||
| 6/8/2026 | Listed for rent | $86,000$25/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #1010703 Report a problem | ||
| 4/29/2026 | Price change | $1,995,000-15.1%$573/sqft |
Source: Out East #393576 Report a problem | ||
| 3/19/2026 | Listed for sale | $2,350,000+30.9%$675/sqft |
Source: Out East #393576 Report a problem | ||
| 10/12/2020 | Listing removed | $1,795,000$515/sqft |
Source: Brown Harris Stevens #50362 Report a problem | ||
| 10/8/2020 | Listed for sale | $1,795,000$515/sqft |
Source: Brown Harris Stevens #50362 Report a problem | ||
| 4/10/2019 | Listing removed | $1,795,000$515/sqft |
Source: Brown Harris Stevens Report a problem | ||
| 4/8/2019 | Listed for sale | $1,795,000$515/sqft |
Source: Brown Harris Stevens Report a problem | ||
| 9/21/2017 | Listing removed | $1,795,000$515/sqft |
Source: Brown Harris Stevens #50362 Report a problem | ||
| 9/19/2017 | Listed for sale | $1,795,000+12.5%$515/sqft |
Source: Brown Harris Stevens #50362 Report a problem | ||
| 5/9/2013 | Listing removed | $1,595,000$458/sqft |
Source: Penelope Moore, Realtor #47077 Report a problem | ||
| 3/20/2013 | Listed for sale | $1,595,000$458/sqft |
Source: Penelope Moore, Realtor #47077 Report a problem | ||
| 10/14/2012 | Listing removed | $1,595,000$458/sqft |
Source: The Corcoran Group #47077 Report a problem | ||
| 6/12/2010 | Listed for sale | $1,595,000-11.1%$458/sqft |
Source: M. Wein Realty Inc. #S1056 Report a problem | ||
| 3/30/2010 | Listing removed | $1,795,000$515/sqft |
Source: Daniel Gale Sotheby's International Realty #*1045963 Report a problem | ||
| 9/17/2008 | Listed for sale | $1,795,000+7080%$515/sqft |
Source: Daniel Gale #*1004703 Report a problem | ||
| 11/26/1996 | Sold | $25,000$7/sqft |
Source: Public Record Report a problem | ||






