3649 Warner Ave, Saint Matthews, KY 40207

Completely Renovated St. Matthews Brick Cape Cod with Custom Amish Kitchen, Luxury Primary Bath, and Private Outdoor Retreat. This 3-bedroom, 2.5-bath brick Cape Cod in St. Matthews has been renovated throughout — kitchen, baths, floors, and backyard — with the kind of specificity that separates a real renovation from a cosmetic one. The arched doorways, decorative brick fireplace, and original architectural details remind you why people love these homes. The updates remind you why this one stands apart. The kitchen was rebuilt from the plumbing out. Sink relocated to the window wall with a new Brizio spray faucet and garbage disposal. Custom dark Amish cabinetry pairs beautifully with Taj Mahal quartzite countertops that extends to a full-height backsplash. A Lazy Susan, dedicated trash cabinet, and under cabinet lighting with integrated outlets make the space as functional as it looks. Brand-new Bosch appliances, including a gas range. The pantry gave way to a custom coffee bar with pull-out organizers. Hardwood flooring replaced tile through the kitchen and landing, and the sunken breakfast nook steps down with its own pendant lighting — a character detail that photographs and lives beautifully. Refinished hardwoods carry through the formal living room and dining room, both anchored by arched doorways that give the main level its architectural identity. The dining room connects naturally to the kitchen, with a Visual Comfort fixture anchoring the space, making the flow effortless for everyday living and entertaining alike. Two well-sized first-floor bedrooms share an updated full bath with original small white hex tile flooring and refreshed fixtures throughout — one bedroom features a wood-plank ceiling that adds warmth and character, currently used as a home office. The half bath features classic black-and-white square tile flooring. The family room offers comfortable separation from the formal spaces, with luxury vinyl plank flooring, a wood-burning brick fireplace, and direct access to the covered patio. Upstairs, the primary suite occupies its own level with vaulted ceilings, a ceiling fan, and carpet. The bath was fully rebuilt: dark vanity, new sinks and faucets, a soaking tub, and a walk-in shower finished with tiled walls, a large glass block window on the back wall, and entry through an arched doorway with a frameless glass door. Visual Comfort lighting throughout, tile floors, all new hardware and light fixtures. A dedicated mini-split handles the upper level independently, year-round.. A dedicated mini-split handles the upper level independently, year-round. The basement adds a nonconforming fourth bedroom/flex room/exercise space, laundry, and terrific storage. Outside, a covered patio with tongue-and-groove ceiling and ceiling fan leads to a new paver patio with built-in fire pit, enclosed by new privacy fencing and fresh landscaping. Anderson replacement windows throughout. Oversized garage. Walk to Seneca Park. Minutes from everything St. Matthews offers. Move in ready. See it in person, schedule your private showing today.