Skip main navigation
ActiveErrorPrice cut: $20K (7/15)
$699,000
4beds
4,438sqft

3864 N Us Highway 231, Greencastle, IN 46135

4beds
4,438sqft
Residential, single family residence
Built in 1879
6.56 Acres
2 Garage spaces
$158 price/sqft

What's special

Modernized kitchenAbundant wildlifePeaceful countryside viewsBreathtaking sunsetsClassic wraparound porchImpressive two-story foyerSoaring ceilings

Step into a piece of Indiana history with the beautifully restored 1879 O'Hair House, a remarkable rural estate set on 6.56 picturesque acres just minutes from Greencastle & the renowned DePauw University campus. Offering nearly 3,500 square feet of living space, this stunning 4-bedroom, 2-bath residence seamlessly blends historic charm with ...

35 days
|
1,698
|
74
|
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID,MLS#: 22108763MLS Logo
Travel times

Living Room

Kitchen

Bedroom

Zillow last checked:

Listing updated:

Listed by:

Chad Hess 765-362-2028,

F.C. Tucker West Central

Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID,MLS#: 22108763MLS Logo

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms
  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 2
  • Full bathrooms: 2
  • Main level bathrooms: 1
  • Main level bedrooms: 1
Primary bedroom
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 135 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 15x9
Bedroom 2
  • Level: Upper
  • Area: 128 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 16x8
Bedroom 3
  • Level: Upper
  • Area: 169 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 13x13
Bedroom 4
  • Level: Upper
  • Area: 210 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 14x15
Dining room
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 324 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 18x18
Family room
  • Level: Upper
  • Area: 208 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 16x13
Foyer
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 168 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 8x21
Kitchen
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 208 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 16x13
Laundry
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 144 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 18x8
Living room
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 210 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 15x14
Mud room
  • Features: Other
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 120 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 10x12
Office
  • Level: Upper
  • Area: 80 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 10x8
Heating
  • Propane
Cooling
  • Central Air
Appliances
  • Included: Gas Cooktop, Propane Water Heater, Refrigerator
  • Laundry: Main Level
Features
  • Breakfast Bar, Entrance Foyer, Hardwood Floors, In-Law Floorplan
  • Flooring: Hardwood
  • Windows: WoodWorkStain/Painted
  • Basement: Cellar,Unfinished,Daylight
  • Number of fireplaces: 2
  • Fireplace features: Family Room, Hearth Room, Wood Burning
Interior area
  • Total structure area: 4,438
  • Total interior livable area: 4,438 sqft
  • Finished area below ground: 0
Video & virtual tour

Property

Parking
  • Total spaces: 2
  • Parking features: Detached, Storage, Workshop in Garage
  • Garage spaces: 2
Features
  • Levels: Two
  • Stories: 2
  • Patio & porch: Covered, Wrap Around
  • Exterior features: Storage, Rain Barrel/Cistern(s)
  • Has view: Yes
  • View description: Pond, Rural, Trees/Woods
  • Water view: Pond
  • Waterfront features: Pond
Lot
  • Size: 6.56 Acres
  • Features: Rural - Not Subdivision, Mature Trees
Details
  • Additional structures: Barn Pole, Guest House, Storage
  • Parcel number: 670529100011000013
  • Horse amenities: None

Construction

Type & style
  • Home type: SingleFamily
  • Architectural style: Italianate
  • Property subtype: Residential, Single Family Residence
Materials
  • Brick
  • Foundation: Block, Partial
Condition
  • New construction: No
  • Year built: 1879

Utilities & green energy

  • Electric: 200+ Amp Service
  • Water: Private

Community & HOA

Community
  • Subdivision: No Subdivision
HOA
  • Has HOA: No
Location
  • Region: Greencastle

Financial & listing details

  • Price per square foot: $158/sqft
  • Tax assessed value: $430,000
  • Annual tax amount: $3,162
  • Date on market: 6/18/2026
  • Cumulative days on market: 37 days

Price history

DateEventPrice
7/15/2026Price change$699,000-2.8%
Source: IRMLS #202624096 Report a problem
6/30/2026Price change$719,000-4.1%$162/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22108763 Report a problem
6/18/2026Listed for sale$749,900+25%$169/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22108763 Report a problem
9/29/2025Sold$600,000-7%$135/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22031807 Report a problem
8/5/2025Pending sale$645,000$145/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22031807 Report a problem
6/17/2025Price change$645,000-4.4%$145/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22031807 Report a problem
5/5/2025Listed for sale$675,000$152/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22031807 Report a problem
4/18/2025Pending sale$675,000$152/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22031807 Report a problem
4/10/2025Listed for sale$675,000+275%$152/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22031807 Report a problem
4/25/2023Sold$180,000$41/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #21910353 Report a problem
3/20/2023Pending sale$180,000$41/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #21910353 Report a problem
3/17/2023Listed for sale$180,000+111.8%$41/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #21910353 Report a problem
1/15/2021Sold$85,000$19/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #21746691 Report a problem
10/21/2020Pending sale$85,000$19/sqft
Source: Prime Real Estate Group #21746691 Report a problem
10/21/2020Listed for sale$85,000-48.5%$19/sqft
Source: Prime Real Estate Group #21746691 Report a problem
11/25/2014Sold$165,000-10.8%$37/sqft
Source: Agent Provided Report a problem
9/30/2014Listed for sale$184,900$42/sqft
Source: Coldwell Banker Putnam Real Estate Center #21317650 Report a problem

Public tax history

YearProperty taxesTax assessment
2025$3,162 +103.3%$430,000 +20.8%
2024$1,555 +3%$356,100 +71.3%
2023$1,509 -47.5%$207,900 +9.4%
2022$2,872 +134.9%$190,100 +7.8%
2021$1,223 +7.9%$176,400
2020$1,133 +26.8%$176,400
2019$894 -0.7%$176,400
2018$901 +8.4%$176,400 +0.9%
2017$831 +1%$174,800 -0.1%
2016$823 -6.5%$175,000 -2.1%
2014$880 -7.2%$178,800 -7.9%
2013$949 +4.3%$194,100 +1.5%
2012$910 -0.9%$191,200 +0.9%
2011$918 -6%$189,500
2010$976 -1.9%$189,500 -1.7%
2009$995 $192,700 -2.2%
2006-- $197,100

Find assessor info on the county website

Monthly payment

Est. payment
$3,885/mo
Principal & interest
$3605
Property taxes
$280
More affordability toolsChevron Right

Estimated market value

Not available

Estimated sales range

Not available

Not available

Climate risks

Explore flood, wildfire, and other predictive climate risk information for this property on First Street®️.

Neighborhood: 46135

Nearby schools

Bainbridge Elementary School
Grades PK-5 • 4.2 miles
6/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
7/10
Academic Progress Rating
5/10
North Putnam Middle School
Grades 6-8 • 6.3 miles
6/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
6/10
Academic Progress Rating
5/10
North Putnam Sr High School
Grades 9-12 • 6.2 miles
10/10
GreatSchools® Rating
College Readiness Rating
10/10

      Nearby cities

      Nearby neighborhoods

      Nearby zip codes

      Other Greencastle Topics

        Search
        Updates
        Favorites
        Plan
        Inbox