Skip main navigation
Off market
  • $1,513,700

    42 New York Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

    4beds
    1,985sqft
    Single Family Residence
    Built in 1880
    4,356 Square Feet Lot
    $1,513,700 Zestimate®
    $763/sqft
    $6,892 Estimated rent

    Home value

    $1,513,700

    $1.35M - $1.70M

    $6,892/mo

    Zestimate® history
    Loading
    Loading...

    Owner options

    List your home for rent

    $6,892/mo

    Rent Zestimate®

    Find your next renter with Zillow Rental Manager. Plus, with online applications, you can quickly screen prospective tenants – for free.

    Learn more

    $6,892/mo

    Rent Zestimate®

    Refinance and save

    $11,011/mo

    Est. payment

    Refinancing to a lower rate could help reduce your monthly payments and save thousands over the life of the loan.

    See today's rates

    $11,011/mo

    Est. payment

    Explore your selling options

    Work with a Zillow partner agent

    Leverage their expertise and Zillow's premium Showcase listings to get your home seen by more buyers.

    Get started

    List with your own agent

    Get your home in front of millions of buyers by listing it on Zillow.

    Learn how to do it

    Sell it yourself

    Take full control of how buyers see your home on Zillow by listing For Sale by Owner (FSBO).

    List your home

    What's special

    Cozy wood-burning fireplaceWalls of windowsGuest en-suite bedroomPrimary en-suite bedroomNewly renovated bathroomInviting front foyerPrivate balcony

    Located in the heart of Shelter Island Heights, this 1880s traditional home was completely restored in 2022, blending historic charm with modern comforts. Thoughtfully updated, the home retains its original character while incorporating today's must-have amenities. Original hardwood floors throughout with most windows updated. Step into the inviting front foyer, where the spacious living room to the left stretches from the front to the rear of the home, featuring walls of windows and a cozy wood-burning fireplace. To the right, the dining room, adorned with original stained glass, opens to a recently installed kitchen with Bertazzoni appliances, custom cabinets, and a convenient laundry room. Toward the rear of the home offering privacy, is a guest en-suite bedroom. Upstairs, the second floor features a primary en-suite bedroom on the north side of the house, complete with original arched doors that open onto a private balcony and a newly renovated bathroom. The hallway leads to a third bedroom, a full bath, and a generously sized fourth bedroom. The lower level includes an unfinished basement and garage with direct access to Meadow Lane. Situated in a prime location across from the Heights flagpole and just a short distance from ferry, the beach club and golf club, this timeless Heights home is a rare opportunity. Make it yours today! Heights annual HOA fees are $5,928.95.

    This property is not currently displayed as for sale or rent on Zillow. This may be different from what's on other websites or public sources.

    Zillow last checked:

    Source: Out East,MLS#: 384458

    Facts & features

    Interior

    Bedrooms & bathrooms
    • Bedrooms: 4
    • Bathrooms: 3
    • Full bathrooms: 3
    Rooms
    • Room types: Laundry
    Features
    • Has fireplace: Yes
    Interior area
    • Total structure area: 1,985
    • Total interior livable area: 1,985 sqft

    Property

    Parking
    • Parking features: GarageDetached
    • Has garage: Yes
    Lot
    • Size: 4,356 Square Feet
    Details
    • Parcel number: 0700006000300019001

    Construction

    Type & style
    • Home type: SingleFamily
    • Property subtype: Single Family Residence
    Condition
    • New construction: No
    • Year built: 1880

    Community & HOA

    HOA
    • Has HOA: Yes
    • Services included: Common Charges
    • HOA fee: $493 monthly
    Location
    • Region: Shelter Island Heights

    Financial & listing details

    • Price per square foot: $763/sqft
    • Tax assessed value: $1,542,000
    • Date on market: 10/20/2024
    • Lease term: Contact For Details

    Price history

    DateEventPrice
    6/7/2025Listing removed$1,785,000$899/sqft
    Source: Out East #384458 Report a problem
    5/10/2025Price change$1,785,000-5.8%$899/sqft
    Source: Out East #384458 Report a problem
    10/20/2024Listed for sale$1,895,000+139.9%$955/sqft
    Source: Out East #384458 Report a problem
    10/12/2020Sold$790,000-1.1%$398/sqft
    Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #L3187430 Report a problem
    3/25/2020Listed for sale$799,000$403/sqft
    Source: Corcoran #3187430 Report a problem
    1/20/2020Listing removed$799,000$403/sqft
    Source: Corcoran Group #253818 Report a problem
    1/11/2020Price change$799,000-2.4%$403/sqft
    Source: Corcoran Group #253818 Report a problem
    7/29/2019Price change$819,000-3.5%$413/sqft
    Source: Town & Country Real Estate #345690 Report a problem
    6/17/2019Listed for sale$849,000+61.7%$428/sqft
    Source: Town & Country Real Estate #345690 Report a problem
    2/13/2004Sold$525,000+128.3%$264/sqft
    Source: Public Record Report a problem
    10/2/1998Sold$230,000$116/sqft
    Source: Public Record Report a problem

    Public tax history

    YearProperty taxesTax assessment
    2025-- $1,542,000 +94.7%
    2024-- $792,000
    2023-- $792,000
    2022-- $792,000
    2021-- $792,000 +0.9%
    2020-- $785,000 +14.8%
    2019-- $684,000 +0.4%
    2018-- $681,000 +2.9%
    2017$4,039 $662,000 +3.4%
    2016-- $640,000 +3.9%
    2015-- $616,000 +3.7%
    2014-- $594,000 +3.3%
    2013-- $575,000 -0.2%
    2012-- $576,000 -4.8%
    2011-- $605,000 -5.2%
    2007$3,259 -16.6%$638,200 +9.7%
    2005$3,909 +13.9%$582,000 +22.2%
    2004$3,432 -2.6%$476,200
    2003$3,523 +31.1%$476,200 +98.4%
    2002$2,687 $240,000
    2001-- $240,000
    2000$2,554 $240,000
    Find assessor info on the county website

    Neighborhood: 11965

    Nearby schools

    GreatSchools rating
    Get a cash offer in 3 minutes
    Find out how much your home could sell for in as little as 3 minutes with a no-obligation cash offer.
    Estimated market value
    $1,513,700
    Get a cash offer in 3 minutes
    Find out how much your home could sell for in as little as 3 minutes with a no-obligation cash offer.
    Estimated market value
    $1,513,700