Limited opportunity for this special property! Unique Shelter Island opportunity to find 8.5 acres with unobstructed scenic views that will leave you speechless. This classic property is currently being utilized as a horse farm, with a 3 bedroom main house, 3 stall horse stables, a barn and a pool house/garage with studio and full bath above. The main house features 3 en-suite bedrooms, kitchen, living room, dining room, a den/sunroom off the primary suite and a large mudroom with laundry. The second floor features two large en-suite bedrooms and a bonus room. With all this land, this is a great opportunity to reimagine the current home or to bring your architect and create your own dream. Located in "C Residential" zone, the possibilities are endless, with subdivision opportunities and full development rights. This property and all of its surrounding land promise a lifestyle of unparalleled beauty, adventure, and tranquility., Additional information: Interior Features:Guest Quarters
Sold for $3,500,000
$3,500,000
44 St Marys Road, Shelter Island, NY 11964
3beds
3,225sqft
Single Family Residence, Residential
Built in 1985
8.45 Acres Lot
$-- Zestimate®
$1,085/sqft
$6,554 Estimated rent
Home value
Not available
Estimated sales range
Not available
$6,554/mo
Zestimate® history
Owner options
List your home for rent
$6,554/mo
Rent Zestimate®
Find your next renter with Zillow Rental Manager. Plus, with online applications, you can quickly screen prospective tenants – for free.
$6,554/mo
Rent Zestimate®
Refinance and save
$24,089/mo
Est. payment
Refinancing to a lower rate could help reduce your monthly payments and save thousands over the life of the loan.
$24,089/mo
Est. payment
Explore your selling options
Work with a Zillow partner agent
Leverage their expertise and Zillow's premium Showcase listings to get your home seen by more buyers.
Get startedList with your own agent
Get your home in front of millions of buyers by listing it on Zillow.
Learn how to do itSell it yourself
Take full control of how buyers see your home on Zillow by listing For Sale by Owner (FSBO).
List your homeWhat's special
Zillow last checked:
Listing updated:
Listed by:
Michael Brennan 917-664-3017,
Douglas Elliman Real Estate 631-725-0200
Bought with:
Kay P. Lawson, 10401293246
Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID,MLS#: L3560589
Facts & features
Interior
Bedrooms & bathrooms
- Bedrooms: 3
- Bathrooms: 4
- Full bathrooms: 4
Bedroom 1
- Description: 2 guest ensuite bedrooms, Family Room
- Level: Second
Family room
- Description: Office, Full Bath
- Level: Basement
Kitchen
- Description: Living Room, Dining Room, Laundry/Mud Room, Primary Suite, Sun room/den
- Level: First
Heating
- Forced Air, Propane
Cooling
- Central Air
Appliances
- Included: Cooktop, Dishwasher, Dryer, Oven, Refrigerator, Washer, Oil Water Heater
Features
- Formal Dining, Master Downstairs, Primary Bathroom, Pantry
- Flooring: Hardwood
- Windows: Drapes, Screens
- Basement: Walk-Out Access,Finished
- Attic: Unfinished
- Number of fireplaces: 1
Interior area
- Total structure area: 3,225
- Total interior livable area: 3,225 sqft
Property
Parking
- Parking features: Detached, Private
Features
- Pool features: In Ground
- Has view: Yes
- View description: Panoramic
Lot
- Size: 8.45 Acres
- Dimensions: 8.45
- Residential vegetation: Partially Wooded
Details
- Additional structures: Barn(s), Stable(s)
- Parcel number: 0700015000400004000
- Other equipment: Pool Equip/Cover
Construction
Type & style
- Home type: SingleFamily
- Property subtype: Single Family Residence, Residential
Materials
- Shingle Siding
Condition
- Year built: 1985
- Major remodel year: 1997
Utilities & green energy
- Electric: Generator
- Sewer: Septic Tank
Community & neighborhood
Security
- Security features: Security System
Community
- Community features: Fitness Center
Location
- Region: Shelter Island
Other
Other facts
- Listing agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
Price history
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 2/11/2025 | Sold | $3,500,000$1,085/sqft |
Source:  OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #L3560589 Report a problem | ||
| 11/15/2024 | Sold | $3,500,000-10.3%$1,085/sqft |
Source: Public Record Report a problem | ||
| 7/19/2024 | Pending sale | $3,900,000$1,209/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #3560589 Report a problem | ||
| 6/20/2024 | Listed for sale | $3,900,000-13.2%$1,209/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #3560589 Report a problem | ||
| 5/20/2024 | Listing removed | $4,495,000$1,394/sqft |
Source: Out East #376579 Report a problem | ||
| 10/4/2023 | Listed for sale | $4,495,000-22.5%$1,394/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #3508407 Report a problem | ||
| 7/21/2023 | Listing removed | -- |
Source: Out East Report a problem | ||
| 8/28/2022 | Price change | $5,800,000+22.1%$1,798/sqft |
Source: Out East #367879 Report a problem | ||
| 6/7/2022 | Listed for sale | $4,750,000-8.7%$1,473/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #3400052 Report a problem | ||
| 5/28/2022 | Listing removed | -- |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #3400052 Report a problem | ||
| 5/16/2022 | Price change | $5,200,000-11.9%$1,612/sqft |
Source:  Douglas Elliman #359353 Report a problem | ||
| 4/18/2022 | Price change | $5,900,000-15.7%$1,829/sqft |
Source: Douglas Elliman #359353 Report a problem | ||
| 10/22/2021 | Price change | $7,000,000+21.7%$2,171/sqft |
Source: Douglas Elliman #359353 Report a problem | ||
| 6/23/2021 | Listed for sale | $5,750,000+1073.5%$1,783/sqft |
Source: Douglas Elliman #359353 Report a problem | ||
| 11/13/1996 | Sold | $490,000$152/sqft |
Source: Public Record Report a problem | ||
Public tax history
| Year | Property taxes | Tax assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | -- | $3,105,000 +65.8% |
| 2024 | -- | $1,873,000 +3.9% |
| 2023 | -- | $1,802,000 |
| 2022 | -- | $1,802,000 |
| 2021 | -- | $1,802,000 +1.2% |
| 2020 | -- | $1,780,000 +0.3% |
| 2019 | -- | $1,775,000 +0.4% |
| 2018 | -- | $1,768,000 +4.2% |
| 2017 | $10,195 | $1,697,000 +3.5% |
| 2016 | -- | $1,640,000 +7.5% |
| 2015 | -- | $1,526,000 +3.7% |
| 2014 | -- | $1,472,000 +2.2% |
| 2013 | -- | $1,440,000 -0.9% |
| 2012 | -- | $1,453,000 -4.7% |
| 2011 | -- | $1,525,000 +1.9% |
| 2010 | -- | $1,497,000 -9.9% |
| 2009 | -- | $1,662,000 -0.5% |
| 2008 | -- | $1,670,300 +9% |
| 2007 | $7,612 +6.4% | $1,532,400 +39.3% |
| 2005 | $7,157 +32.9% | $1,100,000 +41.5% |
| 2004 | $5,383 +14.1% | $777,400 +16.7% |
| 2003 | $4,716 -36.8% | $665,900 +2% |
| 2002 | $7,464 | $653,000 |
| 2001 | -- | $653,000 +4.5% |
| 2000 | $6,590 | $625,000 |
Find assessor info on the county website
Neighborhood: 11964
Nearby schools
GreatSchools rating
- 6/10Shelter Island SchoolGrades: PK-12Distance: 0.7 mi
Schools provided by the listing agent
- Middle: Shelter Island School
- High: Shelter Island School
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. This data may not be complete. We recommend contacting the local school district to confirm school assignments for this home.
- New York
- Suffolk County
- Shelter Island
- 11964
- 44 St Marys Road
Nearby cities
Nearby neighborhoods
Nearby zip codes
Other Shelter Island Topics
