Off market

Street View

Zestimate^®

$2,088,600

5 Bay Shore Dr, Shelter Island, NY 11964

3beds

1,674sqft

Single Family Residence

Built in 1954

0.53 Acres Lot

$2,088,600 Zestimate^®

$1,248/sqft

$6,534 Estimated rent

Home value

$2,088,600

$1.65M - $2.69M

$6,534/mo

Zestimate^® history

Owner options

List your home for rent

$6,534/mo

Rent Zestimate^®

Find your next renter with Zillow Rental Manager. Plus, with online applications, you can quickly screen prospective tenants – for free.

Learn more

$6,534/mo

Rent Zestimate^®

Refinance and save

$14,512/mo

Est. payment

Refinancing to a lower rate could help reduce your monthly payments and save thousands over the life of the loan.

See today's rates

$14,512/mo

Est. payment

Explore your selling options

Work with a Zillow partner agent

Leverage their expertise and Zillow's premium Showcase listings to get your home seen by more buyers.

Get started

List with your own agent

Get your home in front of millions of buyers by listing it on Zillow.

Learn how to do it

Sell it yourself

Take full control of how buyers see your home on Zillow by listing For Sale by Owner (FSBO).

List your home

What's special

Waterfront homeSpacious yardCozy beach homeBreathtaking sunrisesNature preserveOverlooking west neck creekOutdoor shower

This waterfront home with deep water dock is a boater's dream. A cozy beach home featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, a 2 car garage, and outdoor shower, all tucked down a quiet dead-end road, in the sought after Silver Beach area. Enjoy breathtaking sunrises from this spacious yard overlooking West Neck Creek, and a nature preserve. This wonderful home is near the most desirable beaches on Shelter Island.

This property is not currently displayed as for sale or rent on Zillow. This may be different from what's on other websites or public sources.

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms

Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2
Full bathrooms: 2

Cooling

Central Air

Features

Has fireplace: Yes

Interior area

Total structure area: 1,674
Total interior livable area: 1,674 sqft

Property

Parking

Parking features: GarageAttached
Has attached garage: Yes

Features

Stories: 1
Has view: Yes
View description: Water
Has water view: Yes
Water view: Water
Waterfront features: Waterfront
Frontage type: Waterfront

Lot

Size: 0.53 Acres

Construction

Type & style

Home type: SingleFamily
Property subtype: Single Family Residence

Condition

New construction: No
Year built: 1954

Community & HOA

Location

Region: Shelter Island

Financial & listing details

Price per square foot: $1,248/sqft
Date on market: 11/22/2024
Lease term: Contact For Details

Price history

Date	Event	Price
8/18/2025	Listing removed	$2,750,000$1,643/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem
7/30/2025	Pending sale	$2,750,000$1,643/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem
7/30/2025	Listing removed	$2,750,000$1,643/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem
7/24/2025	Pending sale	$2,750,000$1,643/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem
7/23/2025	Listing removed	$2,750,000$1,643/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem
7/2/2025	Pending sale	$2,750,000$1,643/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem
6/11/2025	Price change	$2,750,000-8%$1,643/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem
1/28/2025	Price change	$2,990,000-9.4%$1,786/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem
11/22/2024	Listed for sale	$3,300,000$1,971/sqft
Source: Out East #385025 Report a problem