Skip main navigation
Off market
  • Tax assessed value
    $1,725,000

    5 Hagar Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

    3beds
    3,312sqft
    Single Family Residence
    Built in 1962
    1.06 Acres Lot
    $-- Zestimate®
    $521/sqft
    $7,838 Estimated rent

    Home value

    Not available

    Estimated sales range

    Not available

    $7,838/mo

    Zestimate® history
    Loading
    Loading...

    Owner options

    List your home for rent

    $7,838/mo

    Rent Zestimate®

    Find your next renter with Zillow Rental Manager. Plus, with online applications, you can quickly screen prospective tenants – for free.

    Learn more

    $7,838/mo

    Rent Zestimate®

    Refinance and save

    $13,031/mo

    Est. payment

    Refinancing to a lower rate could help reduce your monthly payments and save thousands over the life of the loan.

    See today's rates

    $13,031/mo

    Est. payment

    Explore your selling options

    Work with a Zillow partner agent

    Leverage their expertise and Zillow's premium Showcase listings to get your home seen by more buyers.

    Get started

    List with your own agent

    Get your home in front of millions of buyers by listing it on Zillow.

    Learn how to do it

    Sell it yourself

    Take full control of how buyers see your home on Zillow by listing For Sale by Owner (FSBO).

    List your home

    What's special

    Attached two-car garagePowder roomBreakfast islandSeparate laundry roomTwo walk-in closetsDouble sinksSpacious primary en suite

    Set on 1.06 acres with elevated sunrise vistas, this freshly renovated single-story cottage is fully turn-key. The entry foyer, featuring a powder room and separate laundry room, opens to a bright, vaulted main living space that seamlessly combines living and dining areas, featuring a wood-burning fireplace with raised hearth. Strategically placed windows, including a striking round accent window near the ceiling, perfectly frame captivating views of blue sky and water. Glass doors open to an expansive 1109sf water view deck spanning the center of the rear of the home. The well-appointed kitchen, complete with a breakfast island and service area, is designed for effortless entertaining. The northern wing offers two guest bedrooms with water views, and a spa-like shared bathroom featuring double sinks, a soaking tub, and a separate shower. The spacious primary en suite includes two walk-in closets and a luxurious bath with a steam shower, double sinks, and a private commode room. On the southern side, a library with custom built-ins and water views offers a quiet retreat, with adjacent attached two-car garage and a staircase to the lower level. The partially above-grade basement provides storage and easy outdoor access, along with a generator hook-up for added peace of mind. Down the hill lies a rare offering: half ownership of a serene waterfront peninsula, a natural buffer between the home and shoreline. Meandering footpaths wind through this private sanctuary, where long-legged wading birds, tree toads, crabs, and diamondback terrapins have been seen - a perfect setting for nature lovers and quiet reflection. For boaters, the property is near open waters and a boatyard with recreational amenities. Taxes for Part 3 Hagar Rd: $674.05. Taxes for 5 Hagar Rd: $6623.25. Property taxes per annum as of 2025 are $10,230.

    This property is not currently displayed as for sale or rent on Zillow. This may be different from what's on other websites or public sources.

    Zillow last checked:

    Source: Out East,MLS#: 388150

    Facts & features

    Interior

    Bedrooms & bathrooms
    • Bedrooms: 3
    • Bathrooms: 3
    • Full bathrooms: 2
    • 1/2 bathrooms: 1
    Rooms
    • Room types: Family Room, Laundry, Library
    Cooling
    • Central Air
    Features
    • Basement: Yes
    • Has fireplace: Yes
    Interior area
    • Total structure area: 3,312
    • Total interior livable area: 3,312 sqft

    Property

    Parking
    • Parking features: GarageAttached
    • Has attached garage: Yes
    Features
    • Stories: 1
    • Has view: Yes
    • View description: Water
    • Has water view: Yes
    • Water view: Water
    Lot
    • Size: 1.06 Acres
    Details
    • Parcel number: 0700018000300039000

    Construction

    Type & style
    • Home type: SingleFamily
    • Property subtype: Single Family Residence
    Condition
    • New construction: No
    • Year built: 1962

    Community & HOA

    Location
    • Region: Shelter Island

    Financial & listing details

    • Price per square foot: $521/sqft
    • Tax assessed value: $1,725,000
    • Date on market: 4/24/2025
    • Lease term: Contact For Details

    Price history

    DateEventPrice
    4/24/2025Price change$2,349,000-2.1%$709/sqft
    Source: Out East #388150 Report a problem
    2/10/2025Price change$2,399,000-12.6%$724/sqft
    Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #L3564455 Report a problem
    10/5/2024Price change$2,745,000-5.2%$829/sqft
    Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #3564455 Report a problem
    8/27/2024Price change$2,895,000-6.6%$874/sqft
    Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #3564455 Report a problem
    7/9/2024Listed for sale$3,100,000$936/sqft
    Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #3564455 Report a problem

    Public tax history

    YearProperty taxesTax assessment
    2025-- $1,725,000 +81.8%
    2024-- $949,000
    2023-- $949,000
    2022-- $949,000
    2021-- $949,000 +1%
    2020-- $940,000 +0.2%
    2019-- $938,000 +0.3%
    2018-- $935,000 +2.6%
    2017$5,545 $911,000 +1.2%
    2016-- $900,000 +3.3%
    2015-- $871,000 +0.7%
    2014-- $865,000 +38.2%
    2013-- $626,000 -0.6%
    2012-- $630,000 -4%
    2011-- $656,000 +0.6%
    2010-- $652,000 -9.9%
    2009-- $724,000 -1%
    2008-- $731,600 +4.2%
    2007$3,585 +10%$701,900 +44.7%
    2005$3,257 +16.2%$485,000 +24.6%
    2004$2,804 +17.9%$389,100 +21%
    2003$2,379 +732.3%$321,500 +28.6%
    2002$286 $250,000
    2001-- $250,000
    2000$2,636 $250,000
    Find assessor info on the county website

    Neighborhood: 11964

    Nearby schools

    GreatSchools rating