Skip main navigation
PendingErrorPrice cut: $245K (4/22)
$3,150,000
4beds
2,200sqft

52 S Midway Rd, Shelter Island, NY 11964

4beds
2,200sqft
Single family residence
Built in 1908
0.88 Acres
None
$1,432 price/sqft

What's special

Around the bend from Turkem's Rest and a short paddle from Salt and Shipwreck, this recently renovated, 4-bedroom, circa 1908 Shelter Island farmhouse, on a shy acre, is perched above Menantic Creek with a substantial dock and profits from panoramic water views with southwestern exposure for magical sunsets. Wide waterfront vistas ...

335 days
|
77
|
2
|
Source: Out East,MLS#: 390309
Travel times

Living Room

Kitchen

Primary Bedroom

Zillow last checked:

Listed by:

The Agency 631-899-3224,

Shane Donahue - Real Estate Sales Person 510-333-3317

Source: Out East,MLS#: 390309

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms
  • Bedrooms: 4
  • Bathrooms: 3
  • Full bathrooms: 3
Cooling
  • Central Air
Features
  • Basement: Yes
  • Has fireplace: Yes
Interior area
  • Total structure area: 2,200
  • Total interior livable area: 2,200 sqft

Property

Parking
  • Parking features: None
Features
  • Stories: 2
Lot
  • Size: 0.88 Acres
Details
  • Parcel number: 0700019000100018000

Construction

Type & style
  • Home type: SingleFamily
  • Property subtype: Single Family Residence
Condition
  • New construction: No
  • Year built: 1908

Community & HOA

Location
  • Region: Shelter Island

Financial & listing details

  • Price per square foot: $1,432/sqft
  • Tax assessed value: $2,606,000
  • Date on market: 7/30/2025
  • Lease term: Contact For Details

Price history

DateEventPrice
5/20/2026Contingent$3,150,000$1,432/sqft
Source: NY State MLS #11541620 Report a problem
5/20/2026Pending sale$3,150,000$1,432/sqft
Source: Out East #390309 Report a problem
4/22/2026Price change$3,150,000-7.2%$1,432/sqft
Source: Out East #390309 Report a problem
3/9/2026Price change$3,395,000-9.5%$1,543/sqft
Source: Out East #390309 Report a problem
7/30/2025Listed for sale$3,750,000+4.3%$1,705/sqft
Source: NY State MLS #11541620 Report a problem
4/19/2025Listing removed$3,595,000$1,634/sqft
Source: Out East #383005 Report a problem
7/27/2024Listed for sale$3,595,000+112.1%$1,634/sqft
Source: Out East #383005 Report a problem
10/28/2022Listed for rent$40,000-4.8%$18/sqft
Source: Out East #369714 Report a problem
5/14/2020Listing removed$42,000$19/sqft
Source: The Corcoran Group #111983 Report a problem
5/13/2020Listing removed$1,695,000$770/sqft
Source: Corcoran - EE Shelter Island #345054 Report a problem
5/7/2020Listed for rent$42,000$19/sqft
Source: The Corcoran Group #111983 Report a problem
3/6/2020Price change$1,695,000-1.7%$770/sqft
Source: Corcoran - EE Shelter Island #345054 Report a problem
2/25/2020Listing removed$42,000$19/sqft
Source: The Corcoran Group #111983 Report a problem
2/4/2020Listed for rent$42,000+200%$19/sqft
Source: The Corcoran Group #111983 Report a problem
10/21/2019Price change$1,725,000-3.9%$784/sqft
Source: Corcoran Group #345054 Report a problem
8/10/2019Price change$1,795,000-5.5%$816/sqft
Source: Corcoran Group #345054 Report a problem
6/18/2019Listing removed$14,000$6/sqft
Source: Shelter Island Report a problem
5/24/2019Listed for sale$1,900,000$864/sqft
Source: Corcoran Group Report a problem
5/8/2019Price change$14,000-66.7%$6/sqft
Source: Shelter Island Report a problem
4/27/2019Price change$42,000+200%$19/sqft
Source: The Corcoran Group #111983 Report a problem
4/9/2019Price change$14,000+16.7%$6/sqft
Source: Shelter Island Report a problem
2/14/2019Listed for rent$12,000-65.7%$5/sqft
Source: Corcoran Group Shelter Island Office #111983 Report a problem
12/8/2015Listing removed$35,000$16/sqft
Source: M. Wein Realty Inc. #R183 Report a problem
5/8/2015Listed for rent$35,000$16/sqft
Source: LinkUSystems, Inc. #R183 Report a problem

Public tax history

YearProperty taxesTax assessment
2025-- $2,606,000 +53.3%
2024-- $1,700,000
2023-- $1,700,000
2022-- $1,700,000 +0.3%
2021-- $1,695,000 -10%
2020-- $1,884,000 +0.2%
2019-- $1,880,000 +8.9%
2018-- $1,727,000 +3.3%
2017$10,439 $1,672,000 +0.7%
2016-- $1,660,000 +7.4%
2015-- $1,545,000 +6%
2014-- $1,457,000 +4.8%
2013-- $1,390,000 +1.5%
2012-- $1,369,000 -2%
2011-- $1,397,000 +0.9%
2010-- $1,385,000 -11%
2009-- $1,556,000 -1.2%
2008-- $1,575,500 +5.2%
2007$7,488 +13.8%$1,497,200 +50.2%
2005$6,582 -9.7%$997,000 -2.9%
2004$7,292 +10.5%$1,027,100 +10.6%
2003$6,600 +57.8%$928,700 +129.3%
2002$4,183 $405,000
2001-- $405,000 +1.3%
2000$4,131 $400,000

Find assessor info on the county website

Monthly payment

Estimated monthly payment$1,822
All calculations are estimates and provided by Zillow, Inc. for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.
HOA fees may include property taxes on listings classified as Co-Ops. Contact the listing agent and/or owner for fee details.
Mortgage interest rates are dependent on a number of factors, including credit score, down payment, and repayment length. Interest rate data provided by Zillow Group Marketplace, Inc. as of 1/1/1970 from various mortgage lenders with which we have lead or other similar arrangements; the Estimated Payment is an average of those rates.
See how much you could borrow to make a competitive offer.
Get pre-qualified

Estimated market value

$2,900,400

$2.76M - $3.05M

$7,194/mo

Climate risks

Explore flood, wildfire, and other predictive climate risk information for this property on First Street®️.

Neighborhood: 11964

Nearby schools

Shelter Island School
Grades PK-12 • 0.8 miles
6/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
6/10
Academic Progress Rating
6/10
College Readiness Rating
6/10

    Nearby cities

    Nearby neighborhoods

    Nearby zip codes

    Other Shelter Island Topics

      Search
      Updates
      Favorites
      Home Loans
      Inbox