Active

$244,900

5538 Pilgrim Dr, Indianapolis, IN 46254

3beds

1,331sqft

$1,698/mo

Get pre-qualified

Residential, Single Family Residence

Built in 1987

10,018 Square Feet Lot

$241,200 Zestimate^®

$184/sqft

$32/mo HOA

What's special

Versatile loft areaSpacious layoutTwo remodeled bathrooms

Well-maintained home located in a quiet and well-kept neighborhood with annual HOA. This property features two remodeled bathrooms, a spacious layout, and a beautiful lot with mature trees. The versatile loft area can easily be converted into a third bedroom, office, or additional living space. Currently owner-occupied, the home will be delivered vacant at closing.

104 days
419
21

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms

Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 3
Full bathrooms: 2
1/2 bathrooms: 1
Main level bathrooms: 1

Primary bedroom

Level: Upper
Area: 168 Square Feet
Dimensions: 14x12

Bedroom 2

Level: Upper
Area: 130 Square Feet
Dimensions: 13x10

Bedroom 3

Level: Upper
Area: 120 Square Feet
Dimensions: 12x10

Dining room

Level: Main
Area: 130 Square Feet
Dimensions: 13x10

Kitchen

Level: Main
Area: 121 Square Feet
Dimensions: 11x11

Laundry

Level: Upper
Area: 120 Square Feet
Dimensions: 12x10

Living room

Level: Main
Area: 182 Square Feet
Dimensions: 14x13

Heating

Forced Air

Cooling

Central Air

Appliances

Included: Dishwasher, Electric Oven, Refrigerator

Features

Cathedral Ceiling(s), Entrance Foyer
Has basement: No

Interior area

Total structure area: 1,331
Total interior livable area: 1,331 sqft

Property

Parking

Total spaces: 2
Parking features: Attached
Attached garage spaces: 2

Features

Levels: Two
Stories: 2

Lot

Size: 10,018 Square Feet

Details

Parcel number: 490501124013000600
Horse amenities: None

Construction

Type & style

Home type: SingleFamily
Architectural style: Traditional
Property subtype: Residential, Single Family Residence

Materials

Vinyl With Brick
Foundation: Slab

Condition

New construction: No
Year built: 1987

Utilities & green energy

Water: Public

Community & HOA

Community

Subdivision: Liberty Creek

HOA

Has HOA: Yes
HOA fee: $385 annually

Location

Region: Indianapolis

Financial & listing details

Price per square foot: $184/sqft
Tax assessed value: $210,700
Annual tax amount: $3,988
Date on market: 5/18/2026
Cumulative days on market: 109 days

Estimated market value

$241,200

$229,000 - $253,000

$1,894/mo

Price history

Date	Event	Price
5/18/2026	Listed for sale	$244,900+44.7%$184/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22102283 Report a problem
8/31/2021	Sold	$169,200+3.9%$127/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #21804296 Report a problem
8/16/2021	Pending sale	$162,900$122/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #21804296 Report a problem
8/9/2021	Listed for sale	$162,900+41.7%$122/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #21804296 Report a problem
6/30/2021	Sold	$115,000+43.9%$86/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem
12/10/2007	Sold	$79,900-24.8%$60/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #2765556 Report a problem
5/17/2007	Sold	$106,250$80/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem

Public tax history

Year	Property taxes	Tax assessment
2025	$3,987 +35.3%	$210,700 +18.4%
2024	$2,948 +3.1%	$178,000 +20.8%
2023	$2,858 +116.8%	$147,400 +3.1%
2022	$1,318 +0%	$142,900 +8.4%
2021	$1,318 +5.9%	$131,800
2020	$1,244 +13.8%	$131,800 +3.5%
2019	$1,094 +7.9%	$127,300 +9.2%
2018	$1,013 +6.2%	$116,600 +6.1%
2017	$954 +10.5%	$109,900 +6.2%
2016	$864 +11.7%	$103,500 +6.9%
2014	$773 +19.4%	$96,800 +4.8%
2013	$648	$92,400 -0.3%
2012	$648	$92,700 +6.6%
2011	--	$87,000
2010	$499 +15.4%	$87,000 +4.8%
2009	$433	$83,000 -20.9%
2007	--	$104,900 -1.6%
2006	--	$106,600 +15%
2005	--	$92,700
2004	--	$92,700
2003	--	$92,700 +53.5%
2002	--	$60,400 +200%
2001	--	$20,130
2000	--	$20,130