Skip main navigation
ActivePrice cut: $5K (10/8)
$320,000
2beds
1,404sqft

5607 Carrollton Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220

2beds
1,404sqft
Residential, Single Family Residence
Built in 1927
5,227 Square Feet Lot
$228/sqft

What's special

Tucked just south of the Forest Hills entrance, this 1927 Craftsman bungalow has the kind of charm that is hard to manufacture and easy to fall for. The exterior was freshly painted in a rich red pulled straight from the Craftsman era, and the story starts before you even reach the front door. The glass-enclosed front porch is where mornings slow down. It's the spot for your first cup of coffee while the neighborhood wakes up around you, and it works in every season. Inside, original hardwood floors and painted woodwork run throughout, and the home keeps its sense of history. The living room opens to a separate dining room with space for a full table and real conversation. The kitchen was updated with a lot of thought and a lot of character. Painted cabinets and a warm butcher block countertop set the tone, and a one-of-a-kind tile backsplash gives the room its personality. New stainless steel appliances bring it up to date, and yes, the owner even found room for a dishwasher, which anyone who knows bungalow kitchens will appreciate. Both bedrooms and the full bath are on the main level, which makes everyday living simple. Downstairs, a 25x17 unfinished bonus room that gives you a flexible space or storage space, along with the laundry area and utility sink. Out back, a patio sits under mature trees in a fully fenced yard with room to spread out, and a detached one-car garage adds storage and parking. Then there is the location, which is where this home stands apart. Sidewalks and tree-lined streets lead to the restaurants and shops along College Avenue and 54th Street. The Monon Trail is close enough to become part of your daily routine instead of an occasional outing. This pocket of the city is known for its walkability, and it doesn't take long before you're leaving the car in the garage for dinner, coffee, and weekend errands. This home kept its history intact, updated where it counts, and puts all of it within walking distance of everything worth walking to.

32 days
2,717
211

Likely to sell faster than

Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID,MLS#: 22127664MLS Logo
Travel times

Living Room

Kitchen

Dining Room

Zillow last checked:

Listing updated:

Listed by:

Mel Coutz mel@coutzandco.com,

Highgarden Real Estate,

Lindsey Schrader 317-385-5790,

Highgarden Real Estate

Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID,MLS#: 22127664MLS Logo

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms
  • Bedrooms: 2
  • Bathrooms: 1
  • Full bathrooms: 1
  • Main level bathrooms: 1
  • Main level bedrooms: 2
Primary bedroom
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 110 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 11x10
Bedroom 2
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 100 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 10x10
Bonus room
  • Features: Other
  • Level: Basement
  • Area: 425 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 25x17
Dining room
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 165 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 11x15
Family room
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 253 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 23x11
Kitchen
  • Level: Main
  • Area: 88 Square Feet
  • Dimensions: 8x11
Heating
  • Forced Air
Cooling
  • Central Air
Appliances
  • Included: Dishwasher, Dryer, Gas Water Heater, Gas Oven, Refrigerator, Washer
  • Laundry: In Basement, Sink
Features
  • Smart Thermostat
  • Windows: Wood Work Painted
  • Basement: Partial
  • Number of fireplaces: 1
  • Fireplace features: Living Room, Wood Burning
Interior area
  • Total structure area: 1,404
  • Total interior livable area: 1,404 sqft
  • Finished area below ground: 60

Property

Parking
  • Total spaces: 1
  • Parking features: Detached
  • Garage spaces: 1
  • Details: Garage Parking Other(Guest Street Parking)
Features
  • Levels: One
  • Stories: 1
  • Patio & porch: Glass Enclosed, Patio
  • Exterior features: Lighting
  • Fencing: Fenced,Chain Link,Full
Lot
  • Size: 5,227 Square Feet
  • Features: City Lot, Sidewalks, Storm Sewer, Street Lights, Mature Trees
Details
  • Parcel number: 490612155003000801
  • Horse amenities: None

Construction

Type & style
  • Home type: SingleFamily
  • Architectural style: Bungalow
  • Property subtype: Residential, Single Family Residence
Materials
  • Aluminum Siding
  • Foundation: Block, Partial
Condition
  • Updated/Remodeled
  • New construction: No
  • Year built: 1927

Utilities & green energy

  • Electric: 100 Amp Service
  • Water: Public
  • Utilities for property: Electricity Connected, Sewer Connected, Water Connected

Community & HOA

Community
  • Security: Fire Alarm, Smoke Detector(s)
  • Subdivision: R H Shelhorns
HOA
  • Has HOA: No
Location
  • Region: Indianapolis

Financial & listing details

  • Price per square foot: $228/sqft
  • Tax assessed value: $142,500
  • Annual tax amount: $1,484
  • Date on market: 9/23/2026
  • Cumulative days on market: 33 days
  • Electric utility on property: Yes

Price history

DateEventPrice
10/8/2026Price change$320,000-1.5%$228/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22127664 Report a problem
9/24/2026Listed for sale$325,000+72%$231/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #22127664 Report a problem
6/3/2020Sold$189,000+2.2%$135/sqft
Source: MIBOR as distributed by MLS GRID #21697253 Report a problem
4/20/2020Pending sale$185,000$132/sqft
Source: CENTURY 21 Scheetz #21697253 Report a problem
4/15/2020Price change$185,000-5.1%$132/sqft
Source: CENTURY 21 Scheetz #21697253 Report a problem
3/30/2020Listed for sale$195,000$139/sqft
Source: CENTURY 21 Scheetz #21697253 Report a problem
3/11/2020Pending sale$195,000$139/sqft
Source: CENTURY 21 Scheetz #21697253 Report a problem
3/10/2020Price change$195,000+5.4%$139/sqft
Source: CENTURY 21 Scheetz #21697253 Report a problem
3/5/2020Listing removed$1,300$1/sqft
Source: Owner Report a problem
3/5/2020Listed for sale$185,000$132/sqft
Source: MIBOR REALTOR Association #21697253 Report a problem
2/13/2020Listed for rent$1,300+10.2%$1/sqft
Source: Owner Report a problem
6/1/2017Listing removed$1,180$1/sqft
Source: Owner Report a problem
5/2/2017Listed for rent$1,180$1/sqft
Source: Owner Report a problem

Public tax history

YearProperty taxesTax assessment
2025$1,229 +4.9%$142,500 +18%
2024$1,171 -10.2%$120,800
2023$1,305 +55%$120,800 -2.7%
2022$842 -8.8%$124,100 +30.9%
2021$923 -58.7%$94,800
2020$2,238 -0.9%$94,800
2019$2,258 +11.5%$94,800
2018$2,026 +1.1%$94,800 +1%
2017$2,003 -0.3%$93,900 +1.2%
2016$2,009 +3.2%$92,800 +3.1%
2014$1,946 +10.9%$90,000 +16.7%
2013$1,754 $77,100 -1.4%
2012$1,754 $78,200 +22.6%
2011-- $63,800
2010$1,326 -4.4%$63,800 -2%
2009$1,387 $65,100 -2.4%
2007-- $66,700
Find assessor info on the county website

Monthly payment

Est. payment
$1,995/mo
Principal & interest
$1739
Property taxes
$256
More affordability toolsChevron Right

Estimated market value

Not available

Estimated sales range

Not available

Not available

Climate risks

Explore flood, wildfire, and other predictive climate risk information for this property on First Street®️.

Neighborhood: Meridian Kessler

Nearby schools

Center for Inquiry School 84
Grades K-5 • 0.4 miles
8/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
10/10
Academic Progress Rating
4/10
Broad Ripple Middle School - An IB World School
Grades 6-8 • 1 miles
3/10
GreatSchools® Rating
Test Score Rating
3/10
Shortridge High School
Grades 9-12 • 2.6 miles
5/10
GreatSchools® Rating
College Readiness Rating
5/10