583 N Erie Ave, Lindenhurst, NY 11757

Rare 1997-Built 5-Bedroom on an Oversized Private Lot — Space, Privacy & a Backyard Oasis Welcome to 583 N Erie Avenue — a rare find in Lindenhurst: a spacious 5-bedroom, 2-bath home built in 1997, offering approximately 2,186 square feet of well-maintained living space in a neighborhood where most homes date to the 1950s. Newer construction means modern framing, a smarter layout, and systems you won't find in the typical Lindy capes and ranches. Beyond the five bedrooms, additional finished flex rooms give you room to grow — ideal for a home office, gym, playroom, or guest space. Families needing real square footage will find it here. Step outside and you'll understand what makes this property special. The oversized lot backs to open space — no rear neighbors — offering privacy that's nearly impossible to find on Long Island. Summers are made for the above-ground pool with its custom cedar deck, and the 1,000 sq ft vegetable garden, ringed by established berry plants, produces season after season. Comfort meets efficiency inside: a 24,000 BTU mini-split system delivers whisper-quiet heating and cooling year-round, backed by oil baseboard heat for the coldest snaps, plus an energy-saving heat pump water heater that keeps utility bills low. An attached garage adds storage and convenience. All this in the heart of Lindenhurst — minutes to the LIRR (under an hour to Penn Station), village shops and restaurants on Wellwood Avenue, and the South Shore beaches. Homes like this — newer build, big private lot, flexible space, turn-key outdoor living — almost never come to market here. Shown by appointment. For Sale By Owner.