Historic character. Thoughtful layouts. Exceptional value.
Butler Place combines the architectural charm of a historic Indianapolis property with the features renters appreciate most. Beautiful hardwood floors, distinctive historic details, and well-designed one-bedroom layouts create homes that feel both timeless and functional.
Residents enjoy the convenience of on-site laundry, a fitness center, and abundant parkingamenities that are increasingly difficult to find together in historic communities. Spacious floorplans and practical layouts make everyday living comfortable, while the property's character and craftsmanship provide a warmth and authenticity that newer construction often lacks.
Whether you're relaxing at home, heading to the gym, or enjoying easy access to the surrounding neighborhoods, Butler Place offers a living experience defined by comfort, character, and value.
For renters seeking historic charm, great floorplans, and a location that simply works, Butler Place remains one of Indianapolis' best-kept secrets.
Special offer
Expires December 31, 2026
Apartment building
Studio-1 bed
Pet-friendly
Shared laundry
Available units
Price may not include required fees and charges.
Unit , sortable column | Sqft, sortable column | Available, sortable column | Base rent, sorted ascending |
|---|---|---|---|
 Unit 40 Studio, 1 ba | 292 | Aug 14 | $665 |
 Unit G3 Studio, 1 ba | 435 | Now | $695 |
 Unit 32 1 bd, 1 ba | 634 | Now | $830 |
What's special
Beautiful hardwood floorsSpacious layoutsRenovated bathroomsUpdated kitchens with dishwashersAmple closet space
Videos
Video 1
Unit 40
Unit G3
Unit 32
Office hours
| Day | Open hours |
|---|---|
| Mon - Fri: | 9 am - 5 pm |
| Sat: | 11 am - 2 pm |
| Sun: | Closed |
Facts, features & policies
Building Amenities
Community Rooms
- Fitness Center
Other
- Shared: On-site Laundry
Services & facilities
- Bicycle Storage: Indoor Bike Storage
Policies
Parking
- Off Street Parking
Lease terms
- Less than 1 year
- More than 1 year
- One year
Pet essentials
- DogsAllowedSmall and large OK
- CatsAllowed
Neighborhood: Irvington
Areas of interest
Use our interactive map to explore the neighborhood and see how it matches your interests.
Travel times
Walk, Transit & Bike Scores
Walk Score®
/ 100
Very WalkableTransit Score®
/ 100
Some TransitBike Score®
/ 100
Very BikeableNearby schools in Indianapolis
GreatSchools rating
- 4/10George W. Julian School 57Grades: PK-5Distance: 0.3 mi
- 5/10Arlington Community Middle SchoolGrades: 6-8Distance: 4.1 mi
- 1/10Arsenal Technical High SchoolGrades: 9-12Distance: 3 mi
Nearby apartments for rent
Listing order may reflect relevance, quality, and paid promotion.
Similar apartments for rent
Frequently asked questions
Butler Place is located at 5230 E Washington St in Irvington, Indianapolis, IN. The surrounding area includes approximately 20 restaurants and cafes within 1 mile, such as Lazy Daze Coffeehouse, Coal Yard Coffee, and Jockamo Upper Crust Pizza.
The nearest public transit stop is Washington and Emerson Bus Stop, approximately 0.2 miles away.
Based on the latest Zillow data, the average rent across all unit types in Indianapolis is currently $1,099 per month. Prices vary by neighborhood, floor plan, and building amenities.
Butler Place is located within 0.4 miles of Benton House, 0.5 miles of Kin Hubbard Memorial Park, and 0.7 miles of Club East.
Butler Place is located near 3 grocery stores, including 0.5 miles from Irvington Farmers Market & Art Fair, 0.7 miles from Victory Liquors, and 0.8 miles from Stoney's Liquor. Additional shopping options, including Family Dollar, are approximately 0.3 miles away.
The total price for an apartment unit in Butler Place ranges from $665 to $830. The total price will vary by floor plan, unit size, and unit amenities.
Rent in Indianapolis has increased by $99 month-over-month, according to the latest Zillow rental data.
The schools assigned to Butler Place include George W. Julian School 57, Arlington Community Middle School, and Arsenal Technical High School.
