Step into timeless elegance with this stately 9 bedroom 4.5 bath Federal Style home encompassing over 5,646 square feet of living space. Built in 1890, this grand home is steeped in rich history- once owned by George Macy, the famed tea importer.
This architectural gem showcases classic period details including four fireplaces, intricate woodwork and moldings, high ceilings, and generously proportioned rooms. The gracious formal living and dining room are ideal for inside entertaining, while a specious deck allows for fabulous outdoor entertaining. This home sits on an expansive 1.4 acre lot and includes a 3-car detached garage, mature landscaping, and a commanding presence that reflects its storied past. With nine spacious bedrooms and four and a half baths, this is a rare opportunity to own a piece of history in an area known for it's prestigious homes and legacy properties.
For sale
Price cut: $75K (8/6)
$1,875,000
35 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706
9beds
5,646sqft
Single Family Residence, Residential
Built in 1890
1.4 Acres Lot
$-- Zestimate®
$332/sqft
$-- HOA
What's special
Classic period detailsFour fireplacesNine spacious bedroomsHigh ceilingsIntricate woodwork and moldingsGenerously proportioned roomsMature landscaping
- 145 days
- 1,526
- 64
Zillow last checked:
Listing updated:
Listed by:
Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty 631-647-7013,
Margaret T. Smith SRS CRB CIREC CB 516-578-7153
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID,MLS#: 944725
Facts & features
Interior
Bedrooms & bathrooms
- Bedrooms: 9
- Bathrooms: 5
- Full bathrooms: 4
- 1/2 bathrooms: 1
Primary bedroom
- Description: With Hardwood Floors, Fireplace, Two Walls of Windows and Full Bathroom En-Suite
- Level: Second
Bedroom 1
- Description: With Hardwood Floors
- Level: Second
Bedroom 2
- Description: With Hardwood Floors
- Level: Second
Bedroom 3
- Description: With Hardwood Floors
- Level: Second
Bedroom 4
- Description: With Hardwood Floors
- Level: Second
Bedroom 5
- Description: With Hardwood Floors
- Level: Second
Primary bathroom
- Description: With Double Access: from Hallway and from Primary Bedroom
- Level: Second
Bathroom 1
- Description: Renovated Powder Room off Den
- Level: First
Bathroom 2
- Description: Full Renovated Bathroom
- Level: Second
Bathroom 3
- Description: Full Bathroom with Custom Original Woodwork
- Level: Third
Other
- Description: Entry Foyer with Hardwood Floors, Coat Closet, Entrance to Staircase and Fireplace with Original Gun Cabinet Above
- Level: First
Other
- Description: Sun Room/Great Room with French Doors leading to Entertainers Oversized Deck
- Level: First
Other
- Description: Original Butler's Pantry with Custom Woodworking/ Bar Area
- Level: First
Other
- Description: Mud Room with Access to Back Staircase and Door to Back yard
- Level: First
Other
- Description: 4 Addtional Bedrooms on Third Floor and Walk In Closet
- Level: Third
Basement
- Description: Large Full Basement
- Level: Basement
Den
- Description: With Fireplace, Cork Flooring, and Custom Woodwork Details
- Level: First
Dining room
- Description: Oversized Formal Dining Room Great For Entertaining with Tiffany Stain Glass Piece in Corner Windows and Additional Sitting Room
- Level: First
Kitchen
- Description: With Access to Basement, Mudroom, Butler's Pantry, Sunroom. Original Lockers for Storage
- Level: First
Living room
- Description: With Gorgeous Inlaid Hardwood Floors, Archways into Bonus Sitting Rm/Music Room, Fireplace with Original Delft Tilework
- Level: First
Heating
- Natural Gas
Cooling
- Ductless, Wall/Window Unit(s)
Appliances
- Included: Dishwasher, Disposal, Dryer, Electric Oven, Gas Cooktop, Gas Oven, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s), Trash Compactor, Washer, Gas Water Heater, Wine Refrigerator
Features
- Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Formal Dining, High Ceilings, Primary Bathroom, Storage
- Basement: Full,Partially Finished
- Attic: Storage
- Number of fireplaces: 4
Interior area
- Total structure area: 5,646
- Total interior livable area: 5,646 sqft
Property
Parking
- Total spaces: 3
- Parking features: Garage
- Garage spaces: 3
Features
- Levels: Three Or More
- Patio & porch: Deck, Porch
Lot
- Size: 1.4 Acres
Details
- Parcel number: 0500394000200027000
- Special conditions: None
Construction
Type & style
- Home type: SingleFamily
- Architectural style: Other
- Property subtype: Single Family Residence, Residential
Materials
- Cedar, Frame
Condition
- Year built: 1890
Utilities & green energy
- Sewer: Public Sewer
- Water: Public
- Utilities for property: Natural Gas Connected
Community & HOA
HOA
- Has HOA: No
Location
- Region: Bay Shore
Financial & listing details
- Price per square foot: $332/sqft
- Tax assessed value: $77,900
- Annual tax amount: $25,395
- Date on market: 4/10/2026
- Cumulative days on market: 146 days
- Listing agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell
- Exclusions: Kitchen/Dining Room Chandeliers/Sconces in Sunroom
Estimated market value
Not available
Estimated sales range
Not available
Not available
Price history
| Date | Event | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 8/6/2026 | Price change | $1,875,000-3.8%$332/sqft |
Source:  OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #944725 Report a problem | ||
| 4/30/2026 | Price change | $1,950,000-2.5%$345/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #944725 Report a problem | ||
| 4/10/2026 | Listed for sale | $1,999,999$354/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #944725 Report a problem | ||
| 12/18/2025 | Listing removed | $1,999,999$354/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #847363 Report a problem | ||
| 9/19/2025 | Price change | $1,999,999-14.9%$354/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #847363 Report a problem | ||
| 5/21/2025 | Listed for sale | $2,350,000+104.3%$416/sqft |
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #847363 Report a problem | ||
| 6/17/2013 | Sold | $1,150,000-11.5%$204/sqft |
Source: Public Record Report a problem | ||
| 4/28/2012 | Listing removed | $1,300,000$230/sqft |
Source: Meg Smith and Associates Real Estate #*1121254 Report a problem | ||
| 2/17/2012 | Listed for sale | $1,300,000-13.3%$230/sqft |
Source: NCI Report a problem | ||
| 9/24/2010 | Listing removed | $1,500,000$266/sqft |
Source: Margaret Smith #2304016 Report a problem | ||
| 6/26/2010 | Price change | $1,500,000-11.8%$266/sqft |
Source: Margaret Smith #2304016 Report a problem | ||
| 3/28/2009 | Listed for sale | $1,700,000-10.5%$301/sqft |
Source: Winkler Real Estate #2175370 Report a problem | ||
| 1/1/2009 | Listing removed | $1,900,000$337/sqft |
Source: Coldwell Banker** #35 Report a problem | ||
| 7/12/2008 | Listed for sale | $1,900,000$337/sqft |
Source: Coldwell Banker** #35 Report a problem | ||
Public tax history
| Year | Property taxes | Tax assessment |
|---|---|---|
| 2025 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2024 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2023 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2022 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2021 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2020 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2019 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2018 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2017 | $21,068 | $77,900 |
| 2016 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2015 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2014 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2013 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2012 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2011 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2010 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2009 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2008 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2007 | $16,434 +20.7% | $77,900 |
| 2005 | $13,612 +6.8% | $77,900 |
| 2004 | $12,748 +4.9% | $77,900 |
| 2003 | $12,153 +5.8% | $77,900 |
| 2002 | $11,481 | $77,900 |
| 2001 | -- | $77,900 |
| 2000 | $10,643 | $77,900 |
Find assessor info on the county website
Monthly payment
Climate risks
Neighborhood: 11706
Nearby schools
Schools provided by the listing agent
- Elementary: Brook Avenue Elementary School
- Middle: Bay Shore Middle School
- High: Bay Shore Senior High School
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. This data may not be complete. We recommend contacting the local school district to confirm school assignments for this home.
Similar homes
- $1,599,0006 bd4 ba3.6k sqft75 S Penataquit Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706For Sale
MLS ID #1045401, Maralyn C. Diggin CBR, Listing by: Douglas Elliman Real Estate. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID - $1,300,0006 bd5 ba2.8k sqft108 Awixa Avenue, Bay Shore, NY 11706For Sale
MLS ID #970268, Kristin Scanlon, Listing by: Keller Williams Rty Gold Coast. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID - $2,149,0008 bd6 ba5.1k sqft61 Ocean Avenue, Islip, NY 11751For Sale
MLS ID #1042189, Julie Vitrano SFR, Listing by: OverSouth LLC. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID - $1,650,0006 bd4 ba5.5k sqft33 Meadow Farm Road, East Islip, NY 11730For Sale
MLS ID #1021152, Jeanne De Frisco CBR, Listing by: Netter Real Estate Inc. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID - $1,799,9997 bd5 ba5.7k sqft230 W Islip Road, West Islip, NY 11795For SaleMLS ID #1026344, Martina Scheben, Listing by: Coldwell Banker American Homes. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $2,050,0006 bd4 ba4.5k sqft21 Buttonwood Drive, Dix Hills, NY 11746For SaleMLS ID #871979, Robert A. Korber, Listing by: Signature Premier Properties. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,999,0006 bd4 ba4.1k sqft5 Home Court, Huntington, NY 11743For SaleMLS ID #1038444, Myung Hee Yoon CBR, Listing by: Coldwell Banker American Homes. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,300,0006 bd4 ba3.5k sqft14 New Street, Great River, NY 11739For SaleMLS ID #1038672, Hector V. Castillo, Listing by: Exit Realty Limitless. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $999,9996 bd4 ba2.8k sqft171 Elm Drive, Bay Shore, NY 11706For SaleMLS ID #1040564, Jose Martinez CBR, Listing by: Power Team Realty Corp. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,499,0006 bd5 ba5.4k sqft8 Penn Drive, Dix Hills, NY 11746For SaleMLS ID #1022708, Ivana Nastro, Listing by: Signature Premier Properties. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $2,099,9996 bd5 ba4.4k sqft119 Plainview Road, Woodbury, NY 11797For SaleMLS ID #1005538, Jared Sarney, Listing by: Corcoran SRG Residential. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,050,0008 bd4 ba4k sqft184 Roosevelt Boulevard, Hauppauge, NY 11788For SaleMLS ID #991914, Evan Greene CBR, Listing by: RE/MAX Signature Real Estate. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,199,8888 bd5 ba5k sqft45 Dogwood Road, West Islip, NY 11795For SaleMLS ID #995925, Rahul Jaggi, Listing by: Voro LLC. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,150,0007 bd4 ba3.6k sqft86 Edmore Lane N, West Islip, NY 11795For SaleMLS ID #1011134, Gina Shaw, Listing by: Netter Real Estate Inc. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,388,0008 bd5 ba3.2k sqft47 Bushwick Avenue, Brentwood, NY 11717For SaleMLS ID #1005256, Sima Levy, Listing by: Nest Seekers LLC. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,099,9996 bd5 ba4.1k sqft97 Chestnut Street, Mount Sinai, NY 11766For SaleMLS ID #1045245, Andy Arrieta, Listing by: Arrieta Real Estate Inc. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,889,0006 bd5 ba4.9k sqft1680 lake Avenue, Merrick, NY 11566For SaleMLS ID #1016033, Maria R. Aramanda, Listing by: Gull Realty Inc. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $2,395,0006 bd4 ba4.3k sqft5 Hemingway Drive, Dix Hills, NY 11746For SaleMLS ID #1030573, Zachary F. Frederico, Listing by: OverSouth LLC. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $1,888,8886 bd4 ba3.1k sqft22 Delaware Avenue, Jericho, NY 11753For SaleMLS ID #1024471, Frances Lisner, Listing by: Serhant East End LLC. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
- $2,588,0006 bd4 ba5.3k sqft65 Threepence Drive, Melville, NY 11747For SaleMLS ID #1035727, Michael Jacobson, Listing by: Voro LLC. OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID
