13 Tower Hill Ave, Shelter Island, NY 11964

Located on over 1.5 +/- gated acres in Shelter Island Heights, this recently renovated traditional offers a rare combination of expansive living space, privacy, a regulation-size tennis court, heated Gunite pool, and close proximity to Heights amenities. A stone walkway leads to the front entry foyer; The first level includes finished living space of 1544 sf: a spacious office/media room, recreation room with French doors opening to the grounds, new full bath, library, an additional bedroom and mechanical and laundry rooms. Upstairs, the main living level of 1684sf enjoys elevated views over the surrounding landscape and gently rolling terrain. Designed with an open-concept layout, the living area is centered around a wood-burning fireplace and flows to the dining area with doors opening to the expansive deck and pool area. The separate kitchen has been updated with new cabinetry, appliances, and countertops. Down the hallway are two guest bedrooms, a renovated full bath with double sinks and shower, and a primary en-suite bedroom with an updated bath. To the rear of the home is an approximately 2,228 +/- sq. ft. deck with pergola and outdoor dining area adjoining the 20x40 Gunite pool. A walkway leads to the regulation-size 60x120 tennis court and a 72 +/- sq. ft. pool cabana with sink, complemented by convenient rear road access. Located within close proximity to the Heights Beach Club, North Ferry, golf course, and restaurants, this offering presents an exceptional opportunity in Shelter Island Heights. Property taxes per annum as of 2025 are $7,852.