Pending

$2,500,000

51 Garden St, Sag Harbor, NY 11963

3beds

1,404sqft

Single Family Residence

Built in 1900

7,840 Square Feet Lot

$2,404,100 Zestimate^®

$1,781/sqft

$-- HOA

What's special

Freestanding garageOriginal details and windowsDouble lotOversized lot

Charming mid 1800s traditional perfectly situated within sight of Sag Harbor Cove and two blocks from the central business district on a double lot features a freestanding garage and room for a swimming pool. Original details and windows make this the historical restoration project about which you have always dreamed. Tucked away in a rear corner, the pre-existing and nonconforming siting of the outbuilding (with electric) frees generous portions of the already oversized lot. Imagine being several hundred meters from your boat. Picture your forays into the heart of Sag Harbor Village for your morning coffee, or your evening (restaurant) meal.

37 days

766

35

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms

Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 1
Full bathrooms: 1

Rooms

Room types: Family Room

Features

Basement: Yes
Has fireplace: No

Interior area

Total structure area: 1,404
Total interior livable area: 1,404 sqft

Property

Parking

Parking features: GarageDetached
Has garage: Yes

Features

Stories: 2
Pool features: Room for a Pool

Lot

Size: 7,840 Square Feet

Details

Parcel number: 0903003000200024000

Construction

Type & style

Home type: SingleFamily
Property subtype: Single Family Residence

Condition

New construction: No
Year built: 1900

Community & HOA

Location

Region: Sag Harbor

Financial & listing details

Price per square foot: $1,781/sqft
Tax assessed value: $922,800
Date on market: 6/27/2026
Lease term: Contact For Details

Estimated market value

$2,404,100

$2.28M - $2.52M

$5,827/mo

Price history

Date	Event	Price
7/27/2026	Pending sale	$2,500,000$1,781/sqft
Source: Out East #396575 Report a problem
6/27/2026	Listed for sale	$2,500,000+908.1%$1,781/sqft
Source: Out East #396575 Report a problem
1/22/2017	Listing removed	$15,000$11/sqft
Source: Sotheby's International Realty - Sag Harbor Brokerage #1050352 Report a problem
10/23/2015	Listed for rent	$15,000$11/sqft
Source: Sotheby's International Realty - Sag Harbor Brokerage #1050352 Report a problem
9/26/1997	Sold	$248,000+21%$177/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem
9/6/1994	Sold	$205,000$146/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem

Public tax history

Year	Property taxes	Tax assessment
2025	--	$922,800
2024	--	$922,800
2023	--	$922,800
2022	--	$922,800 +0.2%
2021	--	$921,000
2020	--	$921,000 0%
2019	--	$921,400 +1.5%
2018	--	$907,400
2017	$5,291	$907,400
2016	--	$907,400 +24.2%
2015	--	$730,700
2014	--	$730,700
2013	--	$730,700
2012	--	$730,700
2011	--	$730,700
2007	$3,689 -4.4%	$730,700 +24.7%
2005	$3,860 +4.6%	$586,069 +6371.6%
2004	$3,689 +8.4%	$9,056
2003	$3,404 +10.4%	$9,056
2002	$3,083 +7.9%	$9,056 +0.3%
2001	$2,858 +33.7%	$9,028 +23%
2000	$2,138	$7,340

Find assessor info on the county website

Monthly payment

Estimated monthly payment$1,822

Principal & interest
$1,547
Mortgage insurance
$0
Property taxes
$170
Home insurance
$105
HOA fees
$0
Utilities
Not included

All calculations are estimates and provided by Zillow, Inc. for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.

HOA fees may include property taxes on listings classified as Co-Ops. Contact the listing agent and/or owner for fee details.

Mortgage interest rates are dependent on a number of factors, including credit score, down payment, and repayment length. Interest rate data provided by Zillow Group Marketplace, Inc. as of 1/1/1970 from various mortgage lenders with which we have lead or other similar arrangements; the Estimated Payment is an average of those rates.

See how much you could borrow to make a competitive offer.

Get pre-qualified