Contingent

$895,000

26 New York Ave, Shelter Island Heights, NY 11965

3beds

1,500sqft

Single Family Residence

Built in 2009

5,227 Square Feet Lot

$904,300 Zestimate^®

$597/sqft

$-- HOA

What's special

Central hvacTwo bathsDoll house accessory buildingDining roomThree bedroomsOutdoor showerWrap-around screen-in porch

Shelter Island Heights: Built in 2009 and designed in the style of the 1890's Carpenter Gothic Victorian. This lovely home has all the conveniences of 21st century living with an extra spoonful of charm. Three bedrooms, two baths, chef's kitchen, and dining room. Living room with masonry fireplace with a propane log set, central HVAC, wrap-around screen-in porch, and outdoor shower. Juliette balconies off the primary and guest bedrooms. Full basement with wine cellar, mechanical room and storage. Doll house accessory building. Shelter Island Beach Club , Restaurants, Shops, Tennis, Golf and North Ferry nearby. Please email Angelo for additional information. APICCOZZI@GMAIL.COM DERING HARBOR REAL ESTATE

77 days

242

6

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms

Bedrooms: 3
Bathrooms: 2
Full bathrooms: 2

Rooms

Room types: Laundry

Cooling

Central Air

Features

Basement: Yes
Has fireplace: Yes

Interior area

Total structure area: 1,500
Total interior livable area: 1,500 sqft

Property

Parking

Parking features: None

Features

Stories: 2
Exterior features: Tennis Court(s)

Lot

Size: 5,227 Square Feet

Details

Parcel number: 0700006000400017000

Construction

Type & style

Home type: SingleFamily
Property subtype: Single Family Residence

Condition

New construction: No
Year built: 2009

Community & HOA

Location

Region: Shelter Island Heights

Financial & listing details

Price per square foot: $597/sqft
Tax assessed value: $1,020,000
Date on market: 6/11/2026
Lease term: Contact For Details

Estimated market value

$904,300

$859,000 - $950,000

$5,121/mo

Price history

Date	Event	Price
7/4/2026	Contingent	$895,000$597/sqft
Source: NY State MLS #11816990 Report a problem
6/11/2026	Listed for sale	$895,000+359%$597/sqft
Source: NY State MLS #11816990 Report a problem
10/15/2001	Sold	$195,000+143.8%$130/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem
6/20/1996	Sold	$80,000$53/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem

Public tax history

Year	Property taxes	Tax assessment
2025	--	$1,020,000 +90.7%
2024	--	$535,000
2023	--	$535,000
2022	--	$535,000
2021	--	$535,000 +0.9%
2020	--	$530,000 +0.2%
2019	--	$529,000 +0.4%
2018	--	$527,000 +2.5%
2017	$2,982	$514,000 +3.8%
2016	--	$495,000 +4%
2015	--	$476,000 +0.8%
2014	--	$472,000 +2.8%
2013	--	$459,000
2012	--	$459,000 -4.8%
2011	--	$482,000 +0.8%
2010	--	$478,000 -0.4%
2009	--	$480,000 -1.1%
2008	--	$485,200 +12.9%
2007	$2,196 +31%	$429,900 +51.4%
2005	$1,676 +103.6%	$284,000 +96.3%
2004	$823 +79.5%	$144,700 +60.1%
2003	$459 -50.6%	$90,400 -21.4%
2002	$928	$115,000
2001	--	$115,000 +35.3%
2000	$559	$85,000