Skip main navigation
For sale
    • $1,659,000

    25 Johnny Cake Hill Road, Old Lyme, CT 06371

    4beds
    2,750sqft
    : 
    $9,615/mo
    Get pre-qualified
    Single Family Residence
    Built in 1730
    1.2 Acres Lot
    $-- Zestimate®
    $603/sqft
    $-- HOA

    What's special

    An elegant and lovingly maintained antique colonial situated on 1.2 secluded acres near the Old Lyme Country Club. Recent updates include new landscaping front and back, new hardscaping around the pool deck, a new cedar roof, well tank, and a HVAC system including ductwork. The interior preserves the historic aspects of the home while graciously blending all the amenities of modern life. A formal living room and cozy library frame the front entryway, and lead to a large family room lined with walls of windows and French doors that bring in loads of natural light. Thoughtful classic architectural details throughout the home include wide-plank hardwood floors, custom built-in cabinetry, crown molding, and front and back stairwells. The cheery kitchen is placed conveniently off the dining area, again filled with more windows and French doors leading to the outside patio. With plenty of room for outdoor seating and dining, it is the perfect spot for entertaining friends and hosting family gatherings around the in-ground gunite pool and spa. A lush lawn beyond beckons for yard games and playing fetch with the dog. Upstairs are four distinctive bedrooms. The primary suite has an ensuite bathroom and walk-in closet. There is another bedroom with a second ensuite bath, and two more rooms that share a third bathroom.
    2 days
    867
    71

    Zillow last checked:

    Listing updated:

    Listed by:

    Susan A. Malan (860)767-5011,

    William Pitt Sotheby's Int'l 860-767-7488

    Source: Smart MLS,MLS#: 24201784MLS Logo

      Facts & features

      Interior

      Bedrooms & bathrooms
      • Bedrooms: 4
      • Bathrooms: 4
      • Full bathrooms: 3
      • 1/2 bathrooms: 1
      Primary bedroom
      • Features: Wide Board Floor
      • Level: Upper
      • Area: 244.1 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 17.3 x 14.11
      Bedroom
      • Features: Wide Board Floor
      • Level: Upper
      • Area: 184.87 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 13.9 x 13.3
      Bedroom
      • Features: Wide Board Floor
      • Level: Upper
      • Area: 179.47 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 13.7 x 13.1
      Bedroom
      • Features: Wide Board Floor
      • Level: Upper
      • Area: 110.23 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 9.11 x 12.1
      Den
      • Features: Built-in Features, Wide Board Floor
      • Level: Main
      • Area: 178.16 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 13.6 x 13.1
      Dining room
      • Features: Fireplace, French Doors, Wide Board Floor
      • Level: Main
      • Area: 267.46 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 13.3 x 20.11
      Kitchen
      • Features: Breakfast Bar, Eating Space
      • Level: Main
      • Area: 167.58 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 9.8 x 17.1
      Library
      • Features: Bookcases, Built-in Features, Wide Board Floor
      • Level: Main
      • Area: 199.92 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 13.6 x 14.7
      Living room
      • Features: Bookcases, Built-in Features, Fireplace, Wide Board Floor
      • Level: Main
      • Area: 480.39 Square Feet
      • Dimensions: 20.1 x 23.9
      Heating
      • Forced Air, Oil
      Cooling
      • Central Air
      Appliances
      • Included: Gas Cooktop, Microwave, Range Hood, Refrigerator, Dishwasher, Washer, Dryer, Electric Water Heater, Water Heater
      Features
      • Doors: French Doors
      • Basement: Full,Unfinished
      • Attic: Storage,Walk-up
      • Number of fireplaces: 2
      Interior area
      • Total structure area: 2,750
      • Total interior livable area: 2,750 sqft
      • Finished area above ground: 2,750
      Video & virtual tour

      Property

      Parking
      • Total spaces: 5
      • Parking features: Paved, Off Street, Driveway
      • Has uncovered spaces: Yes
      Features
      • Patio & porch: Patio
      • Exterior features: Fruit Trees, Rain Gutters, Garden, Lighting
      • Has private pool: Yes
      • Pool features: Gunite, In Ground
      Lot
      • Size: 1.2 Acres
      • Features: Few Trees, Level, Landscaped
      Details
      • Parcel number: 1552932
      • Zoning: RU40

      Construction

      Type & style
      • Home type: SingleFamily
      • Architectural style: Antique
      • Property subtype: Single Family Residence
      Materials
      • Shingle Siding
      • Foundation: Stone
      • Roof: Wood
      Condition
      • New construction: No
      • Year built: 1730

      Utilities & green energy

      • Sewer: Septic Tank
      • Water: Well

      Community & HOA

      Community
      • Features: Golf, Health Club, Library, Medical Facilities, Paddle Tennis, Park, Shopping/Mall, Tennis Court(s)
      • Subdivision: Johnnycake Hill
      HOA
      • Has HOA: No
      Location
      • Region: Old Lyme

      Financial & listing details

      • Price per square foot: $603/sqft
      • Tax assessed value: $845,000
      • Annual tax amount: $13,714
      • Date on market: 8/31/2026

        Estimated market value

        Not available

        Estimated sales range

        Not available

        Not available

        Price history

        DateEventPrice
        9/3/2026Listed for sale$1,659,000+58%$603/sqft
        Source: Smart MLS #24201784 Report a problem
        10/15/2025Sold$1,050,000-12.5%$382/sqft
        Source: Smart MLS #24095314 Report a problem
        8/22/2025Pending sale$1,200,000$436/sqft
        Source: Smart MLS #24095314 Report a problem
        7/24/2025Price change$1,200,000-9.4%$436/sqft
        Source: Smart MLS #24095314 Report a problem
        5/27/2025Listed for sale$1,325,000+140.9%$482/sqft
        Source: Smart MLS #24095314 Report a problem
        3/20/1990Sold$550,000+57.1%$200/sqft
        Source: Public Record Report a problem
        2/20/1987Sold$350,000$127/sqft
        Source: Public Record Report a problem

        Public tax history

        YearProperty taxesTax assessment
        2025$13,714 +16%$845,000 +74.4%
        2024$11,822 +3.8%$484,500
        2023$11,386 $484,500
        2022$11,386 +0.9%$484,500
        2021$11,289 +0.4%$484,500
        2020$11,240 -4.2%$484,500 -7.5%
        2019$11,736 +2.3%$523,700
        2018$11,474 +0.7%$523,700
        2017$11,390 +2.6%$523,700
        2016$11,102 +2.8%$523,700
        2015$10,799 $523,700
        Find assessor info on the county website

        Monthly payment

        Est. payment

        Payment breakdown

        Explore the cost of this home by adjusting the details. Changes won't be saved.
        All calculations are estimates and provided by Zillow, Inc. for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.
        HOA fees may include property taxes on listings classified as Co-Ops. Contact the listing agent and/or owner for fee details.
        See how much you could borrow to make a competitive offer.
        Get pre-qualified

        Climate risks

        Neighborhood: 06371

        Getting around

        15 / 100
        Car-Dependent
        17 / 100
        Somewhat Bikeable

        Nearby schools

        GreatSchools rating

        A local agent can set up tours, give advice and negotiate with sellers.

        Browse local experts

        Similar homes

              Nearby cities

              Nearby zip codes

              Other Old Lyme Topics

                Search
                Updates
                Favorites
                Plan
                Inbox