For sale

$2,350,000

5 Marc Street, Shelter Island, NY 11964

4beds

2,777sqft

Single Family Residence, Residential

Built in 2008

0.5 Acres Lot

$-- Zestimate^®

$846/sqft

$-- HOA

What's special

Central airSitting room and officeRecessed lightingGas propane heatFrench doors to balconyHardie board sidingCathedral ceiling

Welcome to your dream getaway where modern luxury meets laid-back coastal charm. This Newly renovated 4 Bedroom 3.5 Bathroom home offers perfect blend of style & tranquility, just moments from beaches, marinas and all that island has to offer. Designer Kitchen with Quartz countertops. custom soft close cabinetry with center island & high end appliances. Located on first floor Primary Bedroom with en-suite, cathedral ceiling and french doors to balcony. 3 additional Bedrooms each with an en-suite. Sunken Den, Sitting Room & office. 5" White Oak hardwood flooring throughout first and second level. Recessed lighting, Level 5 finished walls. Central air, Gas propane heat. Hardie Board siding. Upgraded 200 amp electric. 1 Car garage. Inground gunite pool ( optional ) .50 acre. Experience the best of island living in this beautiful renovated coastal retreat. Completion date July 2026. Still time to pick your colors and more

92 days

359

17

Facts & features

Interior

Bedrooms & bathrooms

Bedrooms: 4
Bathrooms: 4
Full bathrooms: 3
1/2 bathrooms: 1

Other

Description: Ground level Basement / Garage
Level: Basement

Other

Description: Entry Foyer, half bath Living Rm, Den Kitchen, Offioce, Master Bedroom & en-suite, Office
Level: First

Other

Description: Sitting Room, Family Room, 2nd Bedroom w/ ensuite, 3rd Bedroom w/ ensuite, office
Level: Second

Heating

Propane

Cooling

Central Air

Appliances

Included: Dishwasher, ENERGY STAR Qualified Appliances, Gas Range, Microwave, Refrigerator, Stainless Steel Appliance(s)
Laundry: Washer/Dryer Hookup

Features

First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Beamed Ceilings, Cathedral Ceiling(s), Eat-in Kitchen, Entrance Foyer, Kitchen Island, Primary Bathroom, Quartz/Quartzite Counters, Recessed Lighting, Walk-In Closet(s)
Basement: Unfinished
Attic: None
Has fireplace: No

Interior area

Total structure area: 2,777
Total interior livable area: 2,777 sqft

Property

Parking

Total spaces: 1
Parking features: Driveway, Garage
Garage spaces: 1
Has uncovered spaces: Yes

Features

Has private pool: Yes
Pool features: In Ground

Lot

Size: 0.5 Acres

Details

Parcel number: 0700015000400016000
Special conditions: None

Construction

Type & style

Home type: SingleFamily
Architectural style: Colonial
Property subtype: Single Family Residence, Residential

Materials

Frame

Condition

Year built: 2008
Major remodel year: 2026

Utilities & green energy

Sewer: Cesspool
Water: Private
Utilities for property: Electricity Connected, Propane

Community & HOA

HOA

Has HOA: No

Location

Region: Shelter Island

Financial & listing details

Price per square foot: $846/sqft
Tax assessed value: $435,500
Annual tax amount: $3,039
Date on market: 4/29/2026
Cumulative days on market: 93 days
Listing agreement: Exclusive Agency
Electric utility on property: Yes

Estimated market value

Not available

Estimated sales range

Not available

Price history

Date	Event	Price
4/29/2026	Listed for sale	$2,350,000+209.2%$846/sqft
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #991700 Report a problem
5/30/2025	Sold	$760,000-14.6%$274/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem
3/5/2025	Price change	$889,990-1.1%$320/sqft
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #825050 Report a problem
2/16/2025	Listed for sale	$899,990+150%$324/sqft
Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #825050 Report a problem
6/27/2007	Sold	$360,000$130/sqft
Source: Public Record Report a problem

Public tax history

Year	Property taxes	Tax assessment
2025	--	$718,600 +65%
2024	--	$435,500
2023	--	$435,500
2022	--	$435,500
2021	--	$435,500
2020	--	$435,500
2019	--	$435,500 -11.9%
2018	--	$494,400 +14%
2017	$2,932	$433,800 +8.1%
2016	--	$401,200 -2.2%
2015	--	$410,100 -0.7%
2014	--	$413,000 +2.2%
2013	--	$404,000 -1.7%
2012	--	$411,000 -1.7%
2011	--	$418,000 +6.3%
2010	--	$393,100 +11.7%
2009	--	$351,900 +21.4%
2008	--	$289,900 +44.3%
2007	$1,026 +47.6%	$200,900 +94.1%
2005	$695 +20.1%	$103,500 +28.9%
2004	$579 +1.2%	$80,300 +3.9%
2003	$572 +133.2%	$77,300 +80.2%
2002	$245	$42,900
2001	--	$42,900
2000	$452	$42,900

Find assessor info on the county website

Monthly payment

Estimated monthly payment$1,822

Principal & interest
$1,547
Mortgage insurance
$0
Property taxes
$170
Home insurance
$105
HOA fees
$0
Utilities
Not included

All calculations are estimates and provided by Zillow, Inc. for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.

HOA fees may include property taxes on listings classified as Co-Ops. Contact the listing agent and/or owner for fee details.

Mortgage interest rates are dependent on a number of factors, including credit score, down payment, and repayment length. Interest rate data provided by Zillow Group Marketplace, Inc. as of 1/1/1970 from various mortgage lenders with which we have lead or other similar arrangements; the Estimated Payment is an average of those rates.

See how much you could borrow to make a competitive offer.

Get pre-qualified

Climate risks

Neighborhood: 11964

Getting around

32 / 100

Car-Dependent

34 / 100

Somewhat Bikeable

Nearby schools

GreatSchools rating

8/10
Shelter Island School
Grades: PK-12Distance: 0.5 mi

Schools provided by the listing agent

Elementary: Shelter Island School
Middle: Shelter Island School
High: Shelter Island School

Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. This data may not be complete. We recommend contacting the local school district to confirm school assignments for this home.