Skip main navigation
Pending
    • $649,000

    86 Tyler Avenue, West Sayville, NY 11796

    4beds
    1,469sqft
    Loading
    Single Family Residence, Residential
    Built in 1875
    0.46 Acres Lot
    $-- Zestimate®
    $442/sqft
    $-- HOA

    What's special

    Welcome to this enchanting 1870s Colonial Farmhouse! Nestled in the heart of West Sayville, 4 bedroom, 2.5 bathroom home seamlessly blends historic character with modern updates. The main floor features 2 bedrooms, including an updated primary retreat with a new full bath. The eat-in kitchen connects to a convenient first-floor laundry room. Upstairs, you’ll find a 1/2 bath and 2 additional bedrooms, one with a balcony overlooking the backyard. Additional highlights include natural gas heating, a full basement, and a huge yard—perfect for entertaining and gardening. The property also offers a two-car detached garage/workshop. The large deck, with its gabled roof overhang, provides an architectural focal point and a shaded sanctuary. Located south of Sunrise Highway, this rare gem sits on a double-frontage lot, offering plenty of room for expansion or possible subdivision with proper permits. Enjoy close proximity to Main Street's boutique shops and trendy eateries. Boaters and beach lovers will delight in the close proximity to the local marina and the Great South Bay. Proudly situated within the Sayville School District. Don’t miss this opportunity!
    64 days
    |
    73
    |
    1
    |

    Likely to sell faster than

    Zillow last checked:

    Listing updated:

    Listed by:

    Coldwell Banker American Homes 516-334-4333,

    Holly Hladky 516-313-4454

    Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID,MLS#: 990887MLS Logo

      Facts & features

      Interior

      Bedrooms & bathrooms
      • Bedrooms: 4
      • Bathrooms: 3
      • Full bathrooms: 2
      • 1/2 bathrooms: 1
      Bedroom 1
      • Description: Primary suite with Bath
      • Level: First
      Bedroom 2
      • Level: First
      Bedroom 3
      • Level: Second
      Bedroom 4
      • Level: Second
      Bathroom 1
      • Description: Full Bath
      • Level: First
      Bathroom 2
      • Description: Full Bath
      • Level: First
      Bathroom 3
      • Description: 1/2 bath
      • Level: Second
      Basement
      • Description: Full unfinished
      • Level: Basement
      Kitchen
      • Description: Eat in Kitchen
      • Level: First
      Laundry
      • Description: 1st floor laundry room
      • Level: First
      Heating
      • Natural Gas
      Cooling
      • Wall/Window Unit(s)
      Appliances
      • Included: Dishwasher, Dryer, Oven, Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Gas Water Heater
      • Laundry: Washer/Dryer Hookup
      Features
      • First Floor Bedroom, First Floor Full Bath, Pantry, Master Downstairs
      • Flooring: Hardwood
      • Basement: Bilco Door(s),Full,Unfinished
      • Attic: Partial
      • Has fireplace: No
      Interior area
      • Total structure area: 1,930
      • Total interior livable area: 1,469 sqft

      Property

      Parking
      • Total spaces: 4
      • Parking features: Detached, Driveway, Off Street, On Street, Private
      • Garage spaces: 2
      • Carport spaces: 2
      • Has uncovered spaces: Yes
      Features
      • Exterior features: Balcony
      • Fencing: Full
      Lot
      • Size: 0.46 Acres
      • Dimensions: 100 x 204
      • Features: Back Yard, Cleared, Level, Near Shops, Private
      Details
      • Parcel number: 0500381000500023000
      • Special conditions: None
      • Horses can be raised: Yes

      Construction

      Type & style
      • Home type: SingleFamily
      • Architectural style: Colonial
      • Property subtype: Single Family Residence, Residential
      Materials
      • Frame, Vinyl Siding
      Condition
      • Year built: 1875

      Utilities & green energy

      • Sewer: Cesspool
      • Water: Public
      • Utilities for property: Natural Gas Connected, Trash Collection Public

      Community & HOA

      HOA
      • Has HOA: No
      Location
      • Region: West Sayville

      Financial & listing details

      • Price per square foot: $442/sqft
      • Tax assessed value: $29,900
      • Annual tax amount: $10,128
      • Date on market: 5/14/2026
      • Cumulative days on market: 70 days
      • Listing agreement: Exclusive Right To Sell

        Estimated market value

        Not available

        Estimated sales range

        Not available

        Not available

        Price history

        DateEventPrice
        6/10/2026Pending sale$649,000$442/sqft
        Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #990887 Report a problem
        5/19/2026Listing removed$649,000$442/sqft
        Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #990887 Report a problem
        5/14/2026Listed for sale$649,000+54.5%$442/sqft
        Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID #990887 Report a problem
        7/26/2021Sold$420,000+8%$286/sqft
        Source: Public Record Report a problem
        2/5/2020Listing removed$389,000$265/sqft
        Source: Regal King Realty #3128365 Report a problem
        5/20/2019Price change$389,000-2.5%$265/sqft
        Source: Regal King Realty #3128365 Report a problem
        5/14/2019Listed for sale$399,000+48.9%$272/sqft
        Source: Regal King Realty #3128365 Report a problem
        12/30/2009Sold$268,000$182/sqft
        Source: Public Record Report a problem

        Public tax history

        YearProperty taxesTax assessment
        2025-- $29,900
        2024-- $29,900
        2023-- $29,900
        2022-- $29,900
        2021-- $29,900
        2020-- $29,900
        2019-- $29,900
        2018-- $29,900
        2017$7,938 $29,900
        2016-- $29,900
        2015-- $29,900
        2014-- $29,900
        2013-- $29,900
        2012-- $29,900
        2011-- $29,900
        2007$6,720 +333.9%$29,900
        2005$1,549 +22.5%$29,900
        2004$1,265 -69.2%$29,900
        2003$4,105 +250.7%$29,900
        2002$1,170 $29,900
        2001-- $29,900
        2000$1,089 $29,900
        Find assessor info on the county website

        Monthly payment

        Estimated monthly payment$1,822
        All calculations are estimates and provided by Zillow, Inc. for informational purposes only. Actual amounts may vary.
        HOA fees may include property taxes on listings classified as Co-Ops. Contact the listing agent and/or owner for fee details.
        See how much you could borrow to make a competitive offer.
        Get pre-qualified

        Climate risks

        Neighborhood: 11796

        Getting around

        50 / 100
        Somewhat Walkable
        41 / 100
        Somewhat Bikeable

        Nearby schools

        GreatSchools rating
        Schools provided by the listing agent
        • Elementary: Cherry Avenue Elementary School
        • Middle: Sayville Middle School
        • High: Sayville High School

        Source: OneKey® MLS as distributed by MLS GRID. This data may not be complete. We recommend contacting the local school district to confirm school assignments for this home.

        A local agent can set up tours, give advice and negotiate with sellers.

        Browse local experts

        Similar homes

            Nearby cities

            Nearby zip codes

            Other West Sayville Topics

              Search
              Updates
              Favorites
              Plan
              Inbox